Brave Ones, Standing Tall*

If you’re kind enough to read this blog, then you know that I don’t usually continue a topic from one day into the next. That can get tiresome, so I generally avoid it. But as I was putting together my last post, it occurred to me that there are a lot of fictional sleuths who’ve served their country in the armed forces. The military/sleuthing connection makes sense if you think about it; there are certainly some similarities between what cops and other professional detectives do and what members of the military do. So I hope you’ll be kind enough to indulge me going on about this just a bit…

Agatha Christie’s Captain Arthur Hastings is a former member of the military, although he’s not a career soldier. We learn about his service in The Mysterious Affair at Styles, when he spends time at the home of his friend John Cavendish. In this novel, Hastings has been wounded in battle and has just spent a month in a convalescent home. Now he’s on a month’s leave and has been invited to spend it with the Cavendish family at their home Styles Court. Hastings discovers that his friend Hercule Poirot, who’s been displaced by the war, is staying in the nearby village of Styles St. Mary. When the family matriarch Emily Inglethorp is poisoned, Hastings asks Poirot to investigate the case. Poirot is only too glad to assist, since the victim was his benefactor.

Hasting’s war service is mentioned again in The Murder on the Links, in which he and Poirot investigate the stabbing death of Paul Renauld, a Canadian émigré to France. The story begins while Hastings is traveling on a train on business. The train passes through some of the World War I battlefields, and a young woman he meets makes mention of the war. Hastings tells her a bit about his service. He doesn’t expect to meet her again, but when he and Poirot begin to investigate the Renauld murder, he finds that there is a connection between his fellow passenger and the murder.

John D. MacDonald’s Travis McGee is also a military veteran. The novels don’t spend a lot of time discussing his service, but it’s meant something to him. In The Lonely Silver Rain, for instance, he’s hired by Billy Ingraham, an old friend who’s made good, to find Ingraham’s stole boat. McGee finds the boat, but when he goes on board, he also finds three dead bodies, including that of the daughter of a Peruvian diplomat. McGee himself comes under suspicion, which puts his life in danger. So he’s going to have to find out who the murderer is, and that’s not much safer for him. It turns out that the boat theft and murders are related to “turf wars” between established Florida Mafiosos and a new generation of “drug barons,” and McGee isn’t safe from either of them. At one point, McGee is trying to get some information from one of the minor drug bosses, who insists on being paid. McGee goes to the bank where he has money stored in a safety-deposit box:

 

“I have it [the safety-deposit box] only because there are a few little items I would not care to have sunk or burned. Pictures of my mother and father and brother, all long gone. Birth certificate. Army discharge. Some yellowed clippings of my brief prowess as a tight end before they spoiled my knees. One theater ribbon, one Purple Heart, one Silver Star with citation for Sergeant McGee.

 

This novel is the twenty-first and last of the Travis McGee novels, and what’s interesting is the major piece of McGee’s life that we discover in the story. As an aside, one wonders what MacDonald might have done with the character had he lived.

Michael Connelly’s Harry Bosch has also seen military service. During the Vietnam war, he was a “tunnel rat” – one of a group of men who were sent in to destroy underground complexes that the Viet Cong has built. That service comes back to haunt him, you might say, in The Black Echo. In that novel, in which we meet Bosch for the first time, he’s just been demoted to the Hollywood Homicide Division of the L.A.P.D. When the body of William “Billy” Meadows is discovered in a drainpipe, it appears that it’s just one more junkie’s death. But it turns out that Bosch knew Meadows, who was a fellow “tunnel rat.” Bosch doesn’t believe that this is just a case of an overdose, and begins to investigate the case as murder. And as it turns out, he’s right. Meadows’ death is connected to a major bank robbery, and Bosch finds that more is at stake than just a haul of money.

And then there’s Ian Rankin’s John Rebus. Before he became a cop, Rebus served in the U.K.’s Special Air Service (SAS). That service background turns out to be very helpful to him in Knots and Crosses, in which he makes his debut. In that novel, a mysterious killer called The Strangler is kidnapping and killing young Edinburgh girls. There’s a media frenzy since the police can’t seem to catch the killer, but there are no really tangible clues. Meanwhile, Rebus has been receiving cryptic letters and even more cryptic knots as “calling cards.” He dismisses them as cranks, but there’s much more to them than that. When Rebus’ own daughter Samantha “Sam” is abducted by the Strangler, Rebus has no choice but to explore his past, from which he’s been running. With help from his hypnotist brother Michael, Rebus tells the story of his S.A.S. service, and it’s there that we find the key to catching The Strangler.

Julia Spencer-Fleming’s created a very interesting veteran-turned-sleuth. She is the Reverand Clare Fergusson. Fergusson was a combat helicopter pilot for the Eighteenth Airborne Corps who’s now an Episcopal priest in Miller’s Kill, New York. When we first meet her in In the Bleak Midwinter, Fergusson’s first outing, she is getting accustomed to the religious life, the small town in which she now lives, and the coming difficult winter weather. Then a baby is abandoned at the church, and his young mother is brutally murdered. Fergusson, who found the baby, works with Police Chief Russ Van Alstyne to find out who the killer is.

Zoë Sharp’s Charlotte “Charlie” Fox is also a veteran. She was in the British Army until one particular traumatic incident caused her discharge. In her first outing, Killer Instinct, Fox is teaching self-defence classes for women, many of whom have been residents at a local women’s shelter. One night, Fox and a friend are at karaoke night at the New Adelphi Club. Fox’s friend gets into a scuffle with another patron, Susie Hollings, and Fox gets involved in the fray. When Hollings is found dead not long afterwards, the police naturally are interested in Fox. Fox soon learns that Hollings was raped before she was killed, and that not many weeks earlier, another local girl was raped and nearly killed. Fox suspects a connection between the two incidents and the club, so when she gets the chance at a job at the club, she takes it. Then there’s another death and Fox soon finds herself the killer’s next target.

There are several other fictional sleuths such as James Lee Burke’s Dave Robicheaux who have served in the military. There are lots of others, too. It’s an interesting connection that can add some depth and richness to their characters. And a sleuth’s past in the military can also add some interesting plot devices. Which of your favourite sleuths are veterans?

 

 

 

*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Journey’s Out of Harm’s Way.

About these ads

18 Comments

Filed under Agatha Christie, Ian Rankin, James Lee Burke, John D. MacDonald, Julia Spencer-Fleming, Michael Connelly, Zoë Sharp

18 Responses to Brave Ones, Standing Tall*

  1. Mack

    Mickey Spillane’s hardboiled Mike Hammer is mostly out of favor these days for his brutality and misogyny but he is an ex-marine who fought on Guadalcanal. His military service is definitely part of his character and a combat debt plays a major part in I, the Jury.

    It is interesting that MacDonald underplayed McGee as a veteran.

    • Mack – You’re quite right about Hammer. As you say, he’s out of favour now, but he is undeniably a proud veteran. And yes, his military experience is an intrinsic part of his character. Thanks for bringing that up.
       
      I thought it interesting, too, that MacDonald didn’t say too much about McGee’s military background. I’m wondering whether the era might have played a role in that. I have no hard data to support this, but if you consider that the novels were written between 1964 and 1984, during the Vietnam era and of course later, it’s possible that anti-war and anti-military sentiment of the time could have contributed.

  2. As you might be able to guess, I have just read Knots and Crosses ;)

    Apart from that one, Kerrie´s post about Remembrance Day reminded me of Sayers´ The Unpleasantness at the Bellona club where that day plays an important role. And Wimsey´s experiences as a former soldier are also very important in the series, of course.

    • Dorte – LOL! Yes, I guessed that ;-) . And actually, your post (thank you for it!) reminded me of Rebus and that reminded me of his S.A.S. background. Also thanks for the reminder of Lord Peter Wimsey’s service. Yes of course that plays a big role in the series and in his character. I’m very glad you mentioned it :-) .

  3. Margot: When I started reading your post I thought of Travis McGee. While I have no specific source it seemed to me McGee, a veteran of the Korean War, like many veterans of that era was reluctant to talk about his experiences.

    If I remember correctly Joe Pike from Robert Crais is a Vietnam veteran.

    There are numerous post WW I veterans.

    I enjoyed the first two John Madden books by Rennie Airth. The war had a profound impact on Madden.

    There are a pair of women veterans from that war.

    Maisie Dobbs of Jacqueline Winspear was wounded serving as a nurse.

    Bess Crawford of Charles Todd in the opening pages was on a hospital ship that was torpedoed.

    Sorry to run on. As you say many authors have a military background for their sleuths.

    • Bill – It’s interesting your point about veterans of the Korean War. It’s quite possible that his reluctance to say much about his experiences has to do with the war in which he fought. And right you are about Joe Pike. Thanks for the reminder.
       
      And please, no need to worry about running on. Your examples are excellent illustrations of the point I’m making, for which I’m quite grateful. And all of those sleuths are affected by what’s happened to them in war time. I think it’s an important facet of their characters.

  4. Mack

    Pike’s buddy Elvis Cole was an Army Ranger.

  5. I know it was as a medic, but if I remember rightly, Doctor Watson was in service wasn’t he?

  6. Harry Bosch is a Vietnam vet, a theme that is a large part of The Black Echo as Bosch was a “tunnel rat” and the plot of the Black Echo involves a subterranean bank robbery. This same theme is revived in a much later Bosch novel, I think Echo Park or one around that time.
    Jackson Brodie (Kate Atkinson) was in the forces before becoming a policeman and then a private detective, I think?
    I can’t think of any others, but I probably shall after I have submitted this comment!

    • Maxine – Right you are about Harry Bosch. His past as a “tunnel rat” really is an interesting part of his personality, I think. And of course, as you say, it makes for some terrific plot lines as you’ve pointed out.
       
      And right you are about Brodie, too. He was indeed in the army before he was a cop…before he was a P.I. Thanks for the reminder :-) .

  7. Laura DiSilverio’s Emma Ferris was a military cop before she busted her knee. Now she’s a mall cop in Die Buying. I’m hoping Laura does more mysteries with this character.

  8. kathy d.

    Definitely, Harry Bosch’s military background does pop up in his current life.
    Jack Reacher’s does, too, although I read one book in which he took revenge and it was so bloodthirsty, and he enjoyed it, that I swore off the books.
    I’m such a nonfan of militarism in any way, even in fiction, however, my sympathies lie with real-life veterans who have to struggle for health care, including mental health care, disability benefits, housing, jobs … the works.

    • Kathy – I agree; for many real-life veterans, even getting life’s very basic necessities is tremendously difficult. There’s something that seems basically unjust about that, considering their service to the country.
       
      And thanks for the mention of Jack Reacher. I’d forgotten he’s a veteran and yes, it does affect what he does…

  9. Martin Limon has a series that I must get back to: George Sueno and Ernie Bascom are two MPs in Seoul, South Korea.

    Suzanne Arruda writes a series set in Africa shortly after WWI featuring Jade del Cameron, a former nurse in France.

    Sharon Wildwind writes the Elizabeth Pepperhawk series featuring an Army nurse captain who’s returned from Vietnam to Fort Bragg, North Carolina.

    • Cathy – Thank you for adding these sleuths! I haven’t read the Arruda or the Limon series – I will try to look for them. And I haven’t checked out the Wildwind series in a while. I love your contributions :-) .

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s