The World’s Oldest Profession…

It’s a hugely lucrative industry that’s found its way into many cultures. Whenever there’s a group of people willing to pay for sex and another group willing to sell it, there’s a market for prostitution. Prostitutes’ clients run the gamut of socioeconomic statuses, racial and ethnic groups, professions and education levels. And prostitutes themselves run the gamut from the most elite call girls with an “A-list” client base to homeless young women who use the money they earn to buy drugs. Prostitution can be an extremely dangerous business, too, and whether it’s fair or not, it’s often connected to drugs, gangs and criminal activity. Prostitution is prevalent and it’s often associated with illegal activity. So it shouldn’t be surprising that we see it an awful lot in crime fiction.

For instance, in Mickey Spillane’s My Gun is Quick, his sleuth Mike Hammer happens to be in a coffee shop when he meets Nancy Sanford, a down-and-out young woman who’s turned to prostitution. She tells Hammer her hard-luck story and he gives her some money to start over. Within a few days though she’s dead, the victim of a hit-and-run incident. Hammer is fairly certain that Nancy Sanford didn’t die by accident so he begins to investigate. What he finds is that she was collecting evidence against the leaders of a prostitution ring who’d forced the young women involved into the trade. Her plan was to expose those behind this organisation and have them sent to prison but she was killed before she could. So Hammer makes it his personal business to find out who’s responsible for her murder.

We see the image of the “prostitute with a heart of gold” in Ed McBain’s Cop Hater. In that novel, police detective Mike Reardon is shot on his way to the precinct. Detective Steve Carella and his partner Hank Bush are called to the scene and they begin to push very hard on the case since it’s a cop who’s been killed. Then Reardon’s police partner David Foster is murdered on his way home from work. Now it looks as though someone may have a vendetta against that pair of detectives so Carella and Bush look in to Reardon and Foster’s cases to see if they can track down the killer. They pursue one of their leads to a brothel owned by Mama Luz, who’s known Carella for a while. He basically looks the other way when it comes to her business, and she makes sure that her business doesn’t cause Carella any trouble. Here’s the way they greet each other in fact when Carella and a rookie cop arrive at Mama Luz’ brothel:

 

“‘You come on a social call?’ she asked Carella, winking.
‘If I can’t have you, Mama Luz,’ Carella said, ‘I don’t want anybody.’”

 

Mama Luz does what she can to help Carella and even though his trip to the brothel doesn’t really solve the case, Mama Luz is painted as a sympathetic character.

Giorgio Scerbanenco’s A Private Venus introduces us to Dr. Duca Lamberti, who has just been released from prison for euthanasia. He is hired by a rich Milanese industrialist named Auseri to help Auseri’s twenty-two-year-old son Davide, who is an alcoholic. Lamberti agrees a little reluctantly and begins to spend a lot of time with the young man. Slowly he learns why Davide Auseri is an alcoholic: he is convinced that he is directly responsible for the suicide of Alberta Radelli, whose body was discovered in a field on the outskirts of Milan a year earlier. Lamberti suspects there’s more to this story and, mostly to help Davide get on with his life, he looks into the case. It turns out that Alberta Radelli and a friend of hers Livia Ussaro had been experimenting with prostitution although they worked independently (i.e. without a pimp). Then Alberta was drawn into greater danger than she could have imagined. Lamberti suspects she was killed for that reason and not suicide. His belief is supported when he learns that about the same time, a friend of Alberta’s Maurilia Arbati was also killed after being drawn into the same dangerous web. Lamberti enlists Davide’s help and that of Livia Ussaro to catch those responsible for the murders.

In Luiz Alfredo Garcia-Roza’s December Heat, we meet retired police officer Vieira, who gets caught in a web of murder when his girlfriend Lucimar, a prostitute who calls herself Magali, is murdered. On the night of her murder, she and Vieira went out to dinner and Vieira had so much to drink that he doesn’t remember exactly what happened. All he knows is that Magali is dead and his wallet is missing. There’s evidence against Vieira in this murder, but Inspector Espinosa, who knows Vieira and has been assigned this case, is fairly sure that it’s not the kind of murder Vieira would likely have committed. So he begins to dig more deeply into the case to find out who the killer is. In this novel it’s clear that

 

“Hookers weren’t important. Magali had been important to Vieira, and probably to nobody else.

 

But Espinosa is unwilling to let the case die. In the end, he discovers who really killed Magali and why.

In Donna Malane’s Surrender, missing persons expert Diane Rowe begins an investigation of her own when she gets word of the murder of James Patrick “Snow” Wilson. Rowe has a special interest in this murder because shortly before his death Snow had confessed (actually bragged is the better term) to killing Rowe’s sister Niki a year earlier. According to what Snow said, he was paid to kill Niki Rowe but he didn’t say who his “client” was. But Snow was killed in the same way that Niki had been killed, so Rowe thinks that if she can find out who hired Snow she’ll find her sister’s murderer. To do that she has to find out who would have wanted to kill Niki and that leads her into her younger sister’s world of exotic dancing and prostitution. As she learns more about her sister’s life, Rowe meets several of the people involved in the same business as well as their clients and learns that there were sides to her sister’s life that she’d never known. In the end Rowe finds out who the murderer is, and is able too to start coming to terms with Niki’s loss.

There’s also Jill Edmondson’s Dead Light District featuring Toronto private investigator Sasha Jackson. Jackson is hired by brothel owner Candace Curtis, who’s concerned about the disappearance of one of her employees Mary Carmen Santamaria. Jackson agrees to search for her and finds that the prostitution business can be very dangerous. In fact, I don’t think it’s giving away spoilers to say that both Jackson and Curtis become targets themselves.

And then there’s James Craig’s Never Apologise, Never Explain, in which we meet former prostitute Amelia Jacobs. She now works as a maid for Sam Laidlaw, who is still “in the business.” Laidlaw has a young son Jake whose father is local gangster Michael Haggar. Jacobs is concerned because she’s afraid that Haggar may cause trouble for Laidlaw – may even take her son away from her. So Jacobs asks an old acquaintance Inspector John Carlyle to find Haggar and warn him to leave the boy alone. Carlyle agrees but by the time he gets to tracking Haggar down it’s too late; Haggar and Jake have disappeared. Now besides the murder case he’s already working on, Carlyle has to find the missing boy before something far worse happens to him. In this novel, we see prostitutes not in terms of what they do for a living but as humans.

There are also of course many novels such as Anders Roslund and Börge Hellström’s The Vault (AKA Box 21) in which prostitution is painted in an ugly, dangerous and horrific way. Whether it’s legal or illegal in a given place prostitution is a part of many, many cultures. Those who are involved in that business, whether buying or selling sex, have all sorts of personalities and backgrounds. It’s little wonder that their stories find their ways into crime fiction.

About these ads

20 Comments

Filed under Anders Roslund, Börge Hellström, Donna Malane, Ed McBain, Giorgio Scerbanenco, James Craig, Jill Edmondson, Luiz Alfredo Garcia-Roza, Mickey Spillane

20 Responses to The World’s Oldest Profession…

  1. This is a very interesting collection of portrayals of prostitutes in a whole lot of novels — it really is an important topic in a time when the trading of women and even young girls for sex seems to take place across the globe. So many terrible things happen to women against their will, and yet women do also go into prostitution by choice — one assumes, or economic necessity. Did you see the hilarious portrayal of a prostitute in the recent Woody Allen film? Does it make sense to find this sort of thing hilarious? Well, anyway, thanks for your serious discussion here.

    • Dorothy – Thank you :-) – and you are right that some women go into prostitution by choice. That is, they have an economic need and that is their choice of a way to meet it. But a horrifying number of women and young girls are forced into the trade or sold into it by their families. Those practices are nauseating to me; they really are.
       
      I’m sorry to say I’ve not seen that Woody Allen film. You raise an interesting question about whether prostitution can be portrayed in a humourous way. I’ve read a few humourous novels that included characters who were prostitutes but the focus wasn’t really on their profession. I can say this though; I’m pretty certain I wouldn’t be good at writing that kind of story.

  2. I must have read some novels with prostitutes, but I don´t really remember any of them. Perhaps it´s because I tend to stay clear of crime fiction I believe to be hardboiled :)
    I do love “Pretty Woman” though, but I´m not sure it is very realistic ;O

    • Dorte – I have to agree with you about Pretty Woman. I’m not sure how realistic it is either… And I think all of us have one or another type of crime fiction we would rather avoid. That’s what’s good about having so many types within the genre.

  3. kathy d.

    Anyone who has seen the film The Whistleblower (with Rachel Weisz) couldn’t write humorously about prostitution. That is a film based on a book by a woman who was a whistleblower, who went to Bosnia, working for a private security firm. What she saw was horrific: women forced into prostitution, bought and sold, brutalized and even killed. And the money wasn’t theirs either. The real whistleblower was fired as she wouldn’t back off on the investigation and expose as U.N. peacekeepers were participants in the whole sorry mess.
    This is exploitation of women at its worst. I couldn’t watch the whole film.
    Knowing the horrors of how young women, including runaway teens, are exploited even in the States, often held hostage, beaten and forced into acts they would not have wanted to perform, is awful.
    One paragraph in Gail Bowen’s Kaleidoscope of brutality against an 11-year-old girl, who was sexually abused, is enough to know.
    I can’t help but think if adequate jobs were available for all women and if criminal gangs were prevented from carrying out human trafficking, a lot of this would stop.
    I don’t think most women in this situation are like Melina Mercouri in Never on Sunday. Life is sadder, more desperate and tougher, even murderous in this so-called profession.

    • Kathy – You are right that for many young women, the reality of prostitution is far more horrific than most of us could imagine, let alone stomach. And you’re also right that if people don’t think it happens in countries like the US, they are wrong. Thanks too for mentioning Kaleidoscpe; it certainly shows an awful reality about prostitution. Human trafficking and the fact that it is lucrative is another awful reality that adds to the misery of life for a lot of young people forced into prostitution.

  4. I do usually think “hard-boiled” when it comes to prostitution (it doesn’t have much of a presence in cozies), but I think it’s also been in softer reads–prostitutes particularly in the role of informants.

    • Elizabeth – I think you’ve got a well-taken point that there are certain kinds of sub-genres (one of them is cosies) where prostitution doesn’t appear very much. That makes sense too when you consider the audience, the focus and so on. You bring up something else interesting too; prostitutes may play different roles depending on whether the novel is noir, “hardboiled” or some other sub-genre.

  5. Margot: Thanks for an interesting post.

    One of the best mysteries I have read involving prostitutes was Over Tumbled Graves by Jess Walter. The investigation dealt with a serial killer of prostitutes.

    In real life Canada has been dealing for a decade with the Picton case. Picton killed up to 49 women, many of whom were prostitutes, he found on the streets of Vancouver. Our nation has been wrestling with how much more vigorous the investigation would have been if the missing women were not “street women”.

    • Bill – Thanks for bringing up the Picton case. I’ve heard of it but don’t know much about it. It is very sad, but I think you have a point about how the background of the victim(s) affect the vigour with which a case is pursued. We face that issue in the States too and it’s very difficult.
       
      And thanks too for mentioning Over Tumbled Graves. That’s one I’ve actually meant to read and simply haven’t made the time for – yet.

  6. Lots of writers here are new to me. thanks for mentioning them. Shamefully,. I have never read any Mickey Spillane.

  7. I think that Val McDermid and Lynda La Plante use a lot of prostitutes in their books and make them human. We see why they entered into the profession and even their home lives. So far, I’ve never added one to my stories but I think eventually I’ll have one. Not sure how though–witness, suspect, victim, killer?

    • Clarissa – Good point about both authors. And I always think it’s most effective when an author makes a character “feel” human. If we know about that side of a character we can care more. That goes for prostitutes just as it does for any other kind of character. I’ll bet you’d do a good job of making a prostitute character work in one of your stories. That angle wouldn’t be as easy to work into what I do mostly because of the setting and the kind of crime fiction I write. But it’s an interesting though.

  8. I enjoyed Over Tumbled Graves. (But not Pretty Woman which I found rather nauseating in its moral landscape!) As others write, some good examples here of a staple theme in crime fiction. People-trafficking, in particular, is a common theme nowadays. The first time I was aware of it as a theme was in Liza Marklund’s Paradise (which waited a long time for English translation so others used the idea in the interim). Peter James used it in one of his recent Roy Grace novels quite well, and Lee Weeks has written about it from the far eastern perspective in two thrillers that are somewhat sensationalistic. Quite a few of the Scandinavian crime authors have this as a theme in one of their series novels. It is all very sad.

    • Maxine – People trafficking is really so terribly sad. And you’re right, it’s gotten to be a common theme in some kinds of crime novels. It doesn’t seem to be limited to one place or a few places either as your good examples show. It can work as a plot point or theme but in real life honestly it sickens me.
       
      And I don’t blame you at all for finding the “message” aspect, if you will, of Pretty Woman to be off-putting. Thanks too for your endorsement of Over Tumbled Graves. That does it; I must read it soon.

  9. I just finished reading Erle Stanley Gardener’s “The case of the Gilded Lily” in which Perry Mason is looking for a blonde moll who was earlier sent to “entertain” his rich client in a motel room while his blackmailers got the money out of him. Steward G. Bedford is in love with his wife and all he wants to do is keep his wife out of trouble, since the blackmail concerns her past. He chats with the moll, has a few drinks with her, and plays cards. The girl is so touched by his gentlemanly ways that she decides to stop being a moll for gangsters and start a new life.

    My earliest recollection of a prostitute in a novel is “79 Park Avenue” by pulp writer Harold Robbins. In this novel a girl uses her body to power over lusty men she hates and get rich quickly. She is forced to resort to prostitution after her landlord demands she sleep with him since she can’t pay the rent.

    Celebrated writer John Irving’s books have their fair share of prostitutes, in Vienna and elsewere, who are portrayed as very human, very friendly.

    A point of view: prostitutes as murder victims is getting a tad boring. Maybe, someone ought to write about one as an intelligent sleuth.

    • Prashant – Thanks for reminding us that prostitution as a theme has been around for a long time. And it’s interesting the way our view of people in that business is reflected in those novels. You’ve given great examples of some classics that I didn’t mention, so thanks.
       
      You also make an interesting point about having a prostitute or former prostitute as an intelligent sleuth. Leigh Redhead writes the Simone Kirsch series about a former stripper who is now a private investigator. And Charlie Stella’s Agnes Lynn is a former prostitute who “stars” in his Mafiya. But right at the moment I can’t think of a good series that features a prostitute still in the business who is also a sleuth. Please put me right, folks, if I’m missing one.

  10. I love Elaine in Laurence Block’s Matt Scudder books. She is not a caricature in any way. She never really comes to the fore but plays a key role in a lot of Block’s books. It’s very interesting to see how she grows older.

    • Sarah – You know, I’m glad you mentioned Elaine since I forgot to include her. You’re quite right that she’s not a caricature and she is interesting even if she doesn’t “star” in the novels.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s