In The Spotlight: Betty Webb’s Desert Wives

Hello All,

Welcome to another edition of In The Spotlight. Many crime novels do more than just tell the story of a crime, its investigation and its solution. They also address social topics or call attention to social problems. To show you what I mean, let’s take a closer look today at Betty Webb’s Desert Wives, the second in her Lena Jones series.

Jones is a private investigator who, together with her business partner Jimmy Sisiwan, owns Desert Investigations. As Desert Wives begins, Jones and Sisiwan have gone to rescue thirteen-year-old Rebecca Corbett from a polygamist sect. Her father Abel, who has returned to the sect after some time away, has agreed that she will marry the group’s leader Solomon Royal. Her mother Esther, who has since divorced Abel, wants Rebecca to be safe with her.  The group lives in an isolated compound called Purity that straddles the border between Arizona and Utah. The going isn’t easy but Jones and Sisiwan find Rebecca and bring her back to the Arizona side of the border where her mother is waiting. The plan is for Esther to take Rebecca and start a new life away from Abel and Purity.

As she and Rebecca are leaving the compound, Jones sees that Royal has been shot and badly wounded, but there’s no time to do anything about it then. So when Rebecca is safe, Jones calls the police to announce the emergency. Once Rebecca is reunited with her mother, Jones thinks the case is over. Then she gets a call from Esther, who tells her that Royal has died and that she is now under investigation for murder. It’s very likely that Esther will be extradited to Utah to stand trial for a crime she says she didn’t commit. And she is well aware that Solomon Royal had a great deal of power, so that she doesn’t stand much of a chance for a fair hearing. If she loses, Rebecca will be sent back to Purity. So she begs Jones to go to Purity and investigate the murder. Jones agrees and works out a plan to go undercover as the wife of Saul Berkhauser, a disaffected group member whose financial situation has forced him to stay at Purity.

Under that guise, Jones goes to Purity and slowly learns that this group is hiding several dark and very, very ugly secrets. For example, the women of Purity are routinely abused, as are their children, and forced to marry against their will. There’s also the practice of marrying young girls off when they’re as young as thirteen, sometimes even younger, and child molestation is not infrequent. What’s more, there is so much intermarriage that there are a great many children with birth defects and other physical and mental problems. All of this makes Jones so furious and indignant that she can’t at first understand why the women of Purity don’t simply leave. She learns though that it’s not that simple. First, the women have access to very little money. Besides, most of them have several children, so that escaping with them would not be feasible. And few of Purity’s women would be willing to be permanently separated from their children. Finally, several of the women have been raised in Purity, or moved there when they were very young, so they are convinced that they are living ‘the way God wants them to live.’ Jones also discovers that the men are, in their way, just as trapped as the women. They’ve been required to sign over all of their wealth to the group, and few have outside sources of income. What’s worst (at least from my point of view, so feel free to differ with me if you do), local authorities are well aware of what goes on at Purity. But they do nothing about it and in fact, some even quietly support what the group believes. The more Jones looks into what’s really happening at Purity, the more dirty secrets she uncovers, and there aren’t many people to whom she can turn for help.

In fact Jones gets so distracted by what she learns at Purity that at times she finds it hard to focus on the murder she’s trying to solve. But in the end, she discovers who killed Solomon Royal and why.

This novel is as much an exposé of life in a polygamous sect as it is a crime novel. That element is one of the most powerful points about the book. On that score, it is not an easy book to read, particularly when one knows that Webb has ‘done her homework,’ so that this novel strikes one as authentic. The ugly truths about Purity are made all the more haunting because Webb does not fall into the trap of explicitness. Everything is starkly revealed, but it’s not done gratuitously. It’s also worth noting that Webb doesn’t preach (at least I didn’t feel preached at). Rather, the story simply shows what life is like in polygamous groups like Purity. And that makes the story all the more powerful.

Another very important element in the novel is the setting. Purity is located in the high desert ‘wild country’ between Arizona and Utah. It’s stark, beautiful in a wild way, and potentially quite treacherous, and Webb places the reader there clearly:

 

‘Sheer cliffs towered more than three thousand feet above the forested plateau below, where the Virgin River wound its way through red and white sandstone. Lush Ponderosa pine, sycamore, piñon and cottonwood covered the valley, complemented by scarlet plumes of Indian paintbrush and blue columbine.’

 

Although this is gorgeous country, it’s also rugged and adds a sense of real isolation to life at Purity.

The character of Lena Jones is also an interesting element in this novel. She faces several personal demons, including life as a foster child during which she was raped more than once. She also has to deal with nightmares stemming from her early childhood with her mother. So she’s become cynical and unhappy. But you really couldn’t say that she wallows in her past. She’s not an alcoholic nor does she fall into the trap of a self-destructive lifestyle. But she has been badly scarred. She is a strong female protagonist, so readers who do not like the scenario of the ‘helpless female’ will be pleased. She is outspoken, independent and sometimes speaks without thinking, but she’s not what you would call a ‘loose cannon.’ Her past has given her real sympathy for those in need and that makes the work of uncovering what’s going on at Purity all the more difficult for her. It’s not hard to be on her side as she tries to get past her own personal feelings and find out the truth.

The mystery itself is solved, and not by magic, but it’s not the central element of the novel. Still, the search for the truth adds to the already strong sense of tension and suspense that’s caused by the facts of life at Purity.

Desert Wives is a very difficult book to read given its subject matter. But the pace is brisk and the story is told from the viewpoint of a sympathetic protagonist. And it takes place against a starkly beautiful physical backdrop. But what’s your view? Have you read Desert Wives? If you have, what elements do you see in it?

Want to read some other thoughts about the novel? Please check out this excellent review from Bernadette at Reactions to Reading and this excellent review from Maxine at Petrona. Both are blogs that richly deserve to be on any crime fiction lover’s blog roll.

 

 

 

Coming Up On In The Spotlight

 

Monday 3 December/Tuesday 4 December – March Violets – Philip Kerr

Monday 10 December/Tuesday 11 December – Maisie Dobbs – Jacqueline Winspear

Monday 17 December/Tuesday 18 December – Project Nirvana – Stefan Tegenfalk

12 Comments

Filed under Betty Webb, Desert Wives

12 responses to “In The Spotlight: Betty Webb’s Desert Wives

  1. This is my favorite of all of Betty’s mysteries, partly because she deals with a difficult and shocking subject with courage and partly because it told us so much about Lena Jones. I heard Betty speak at a conference once when she told about the hate mail and other disturbing harassment incidents she suffered after writing this novel, so I can’t help but admire her willingness to stand up for the victims.

    • Pat – I’m not surprised that there was a lot of hate mail and worse after this novel was written. This is most definitely not an easy or popular topic and I too give Webb quite a lot of credit for tackling it. And yet, honestly, I didn’t feel preached at. I can understand why you like it as much as you do. It’s a powerful novel I think.

  2. I always find your spotlights so informative and entertaining, not to mention that I usually wind up adding another book to my wish list or my TBR list. This is a series I wasn’t familiar with, but it sounds intriguing. Thanks for the spotlight.

    Mason
    Thoughts in Progress

    • Mason – I’m glad you enjoy this feature. I’ll admit that this one isn’t an easy book to read. It’s by no means light. But It’s got solid characters ad such a good sense of place. And it tells a compelling story.

  3. Thanks for the shout out Margot and for spotlighting another great book, I think you have picked up on all the most important elements of it.

    Since finishing the book myself a few days ago I can’t help but reflect upon how difficult it must be to have a really clear image of the social/political themes you want to bring up in a novel (as Webb clearly did) and then try to create story around them – especially entertaining story without it becoming a polemic that turns people off. I found the social commentary aspects of the book fascinating because it is not a subject I was terribly aware of and I automatically sided with the women and children so poorly treated at Purity which I suppose was the effect Webb was after. But I wonder if perhaps the book is a bit too strident if she hopes it will speak to people who are close to that world – e.g. a law enforcement officer or social services worker who has to deal with the real world versions of Purity – I suspect the depiction of those types of characters in the book might turn such potential readers off – perhaps a slightly more balanced view of their role might have enabled the book to do more good than ‘preach to the converted’ for want of a better term,

    • Bernadette – Oh, it’s my pleasure to mention your terrific blog. You make an absolutely fascinating and well-taken point too about the way Webb drew her characters. Readers (at least this one) automatically have sympathy for the women and children of Purity. I may be biased but I don’t see how one could read this book and not care about them. And yet, if Webb’s larger goal is to call attention to those abuses and spark social change, then the people most in a position to make those changes need to support them. Those characters are not treated in the least bit well in the novel overall and yes, I could see how someone reading it might think it’s not balanced on that account. I don’t think that way; as you say (and said in your own review) it didn’t feel preachy to me. I wonder what readers who have more knowledge of polygamist groups than I do thought of it.

  4. This sounds great Margot – with this kind of subject matter it is always really reassuring to be told that that the author has properly researched the project. For me it means I otherwise just can’t take it seriously and there are some topics that can;t merely be used as a colourful backdrop after all. I have not read this one yet but hope to remedy this soon – thanks again.

    • Sergio – Well-put. This is definitely subject matter that needs to be handled carefully and in a knowledgeable way. One reason is what you clearly pointed out: otherwise the reader won’t take the story seriously. Another is that if the author has an agenda as Webb does, it’s likely to have more impact if the material’s been researched and is preseted in a believable way. It’s not an easy book to read but I hope that if you read it, you’ll be glad that you did.

  5. Excellent analysis of an impressive book, Margot — in which I think the issues became more important than the mystery, but not in a bad way. And thank you very much for so kindly linking to my review of it.

    • Maxine – Thanks for the kind words. I agree with you 100% that in this case, the issues are more important than the mystery is, but it works. In my opinion, Webb invites us to care about the characters and issues, so the story (in my opinion) doesn’t falter. And it’s my great pleasure to direct folks to your excellent blog.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s