A lot of people think of the word love in its sense of romance between two people. That’s especially true on days like today (As I write this, it’s Valentine’s Day). Other people may think of love among family members or even the strong attachments we have to close friends. They’re all different ways of thinking about that same driving force. But there are other ways to look at that force too. For instance that same passion drives people who love what they do. If you’ve ever had a teacher or professor who inspired you because of that person’s passion for the subject, you know what I mean. If you’ve ever had your hair done expertly by someone who absolutely loves making people feel good about the way they look, you know what I mean. If you’re a writer with a ‘day job’ who juggles everything frantically because you are passionate about writing, you know what I mean too. Doing what you love is energising and fulfilling. And in fiction, characters who do what they love because they love it can add life and zest to a novel. Just a quick look at crime fiction should show what I mean.
In Agatha Christie’s The Hollow (AKA Murder After Hours) we meet Harley Street specialist Dr. John Christow. He is passionate about medicine and medical research and the one thing that drives him more than anything else is his love for the field. In fact, it helps to make him one of the most ‘alive’ characters in this story. One week-end, he and his wife Gerda are invited to the country home of Sir Henry and Lady Lucy Angkatell. Also invited are a few other Angkatell relations. Among them is Henrietta Savernake, who is as passionate about her sculpture as Christow is about medicine. Hercule Poirot has taken a nearby cottage for getaways and the Angkatells invite him for lunch on the Sunday. When he arrives though, Poirot is met by a scene he thinks has been arranged for his ‘amusement.’ Christow’s been shot next to the swimming pool and the person who seems to have shot him is standing holding the gun. Within seconds Poirot sees that this not a tableau; it’s all too real. He works with Inspector Grange to find out who show Christow and why. Throughout the novel we see how Christow’s passion for what he does has impacted him and how Savernake’s passion for what she does influences her. That passion isn’t really the reason Christow was murdered. But it forms an important theme in this novel.
A passion for archaeology is what drives Harry Steadman in Peter Robinson’s A Dedicated Man. Steadman inherited a good deal of money, so he’s been able to leave his position at Leeds University and move to Yorkshire, where he can follow his dream of excavating the Roman ruins there. He and his wife Emma are more or less settled in Yorkshire and Steadman’s been working on a large excavation plan. Then one day he’s found bludgeoned to death. DI Alan Banks and his team investigate the murder and they soon find that more than one person had a motive. One of the interesting themes in this novel is the way that Steadman’s love for his profession and his passion for what he does influences all of the people in his life.
Kerry Greenwood’s Corinna Chapman is a baker who lives and works in Melbourne. At one time she was an accountant, until she realised that accounting simply didn’t matter to her. When she turned to baking she found a career for which she has a true love, even if it does mean getting up at four in the morning. For her, making bread is real. In fact, in Trick or Treat, she learns just how much baking means to her. In one of the plot threads of that story, there’s evidence that some of the local bread may have been poisoned with ergot. So Chapman’s bakery has to be quarantined while the authorities search for signs of ergot. She’s devastated that she can’t do what she loves and what means the most to her. She’s just as upset at the possibility that her bread could have caused harm. In the end, it gives Chapman a real sense that everything will be all right when she’s able to re-open her bakery and start creating bread again. Chapman passes on that passion (or perhaps awakens it) too. Her assistant Jason has just as much of a love for creating; in his case it’s muffins. In fact one of his nicknames is The Muffin Man. Nothing makes him happier than to come up with a delicious new variety or to perfect one he’s already created.
Val McDermid’s The Grave Tattoo introduces us to Wordsworth scholar Jane Gresham. She is passionate about writing and about Wordsworth and puts up with the difficulties of being on the ‘bottom rung’ of academia as she works on her scholarship. Then she gets word that a body has been discovered in a bog not far from where she grew up in the Lake District. It’s possible that the body belongs to Fletcher Christian of H.M.S. Bounty fame. There always were stories that he didn’t die on Pitcairn Island as had been reported. If he made his way back to the Lake District, nothing would be more natural than that he might contact his good friend Wordsworth. If that happened, so Gresham reasons, Wordsworth would likely have written about the real story of what happened to his friend. And that could very well be the unpublished Wordsworth manuscript that Gresham has always believed existed. So she travels eagerly to the Lake District to find out if such a manuscript exists. Gresham soon gets mixed up in murder as first one, than another lead in her search turns up dead. In order to clear her name, she’ll have to discover who the killer is and hope that that will also lead her to the manuscript.
Martin Edwards’ Daniel Kind also loves what he does. He’s an Oxford historian whose passion for history is one of the driving forces in his life. That love of history also gives him valuable insights into the ‘cold cases’ that DCI Hannah Scarlett and her Cold Case Review team investigate. Scarlett used to work with Kind’s father Ben, so the two have known each other for some time. Scarlett may not be the keen historian that Kind is, but she respects his passion and finds that his knowledge is often helpful. For instance, his research into Lake District writer Thomas de Quincey is key to solving three murders in The Serpent Pool. Kind’s interest in history is infectious too; in fact, at the beginning of the series he moves to the Lake District in part because he’s had enough of being a ‘history celebrity.’ He’s much in demand for lectures and guest teaching and it’s easy to see why. He loves what he does.
There are of course fictional sleuths who are passionate about solving cases. That for instance is why Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes does what he does. He loves solving problems and dealing with his cases feeds that passion. It’s the same for Colin Dexter’s Inspector Morse and Michael Connelly’s Hary Bosch too. And I’m sure that you can think of other fictional sleuths who are driven by their passion for solving cases.
Doing what you love and are passionate about can be one of life’s truly fulfilling experiences. In fact, Billy Joel has said, ‘If you are not doing what you love, you are wasting your time.’ I don’t know if I’d put it in terms like that, but I think Mr. Joel has a point…
*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Marvin Hamlisch and Edward Kleban’s What I Did For Love.













Margot, when you talk about characters with a real passion for what they do, the one who comes to my mind is Agatha Troy, the painter wife of Ngaio Marsh’s detective, Roderick Alleyn. Over the course of several novels in which she appears, Agatha Troy Alleyn emerges as a marvelous painter and knowledgeable critic, with the kind of quirks that you might expect to find in a first-rate artist’s personality. Troy is a successful and very talented artist, deeply passionate about her art, and it is that passion which occasionally draws her into the setting of a murder mystery, much as her husband may dislike the idea of her involvement. In fact, she really meets Alleyn in the course of a murder among her art students (Artists in Crime), and she plays a significant role in uncovering an art fraud ring (Clutch of Constables), among other cases. She’s one of my favorite fictional characters; frankly, I admire her more than I like her husband!
Les – I can’t tell you how glad I am that you mentioned Agatha Troy! I almost included her but I didn’t want to go on and on, so I am very glad you did. I couldn’t agree more that she is an excellent example of a character who is truly driven by her passion for her work. Thanks for filling in that gap.
‘If you are not doing what you love, you are wasting your time.’ Of course, not all of us have the luxury of doing what we love full-time, but I agree with Mr Joel’s sentiment and the importance of making time for what you love.
Happy Valentine’s Day, Margot!
Angela – Well-said! On all counts. I think it really is important to do what you love. And Happy Valentine’s Day (well I hope it was one) to you too.
Good post for today. I wish I could copy Corinna Chapman’s life and open up a nice, cozy muffin, cookie, cake bakery — without the calories, of course, as I’d eat a great deal of the products.
I think V.I. Warshawski loves solving cases and I think so do Guido Brunetti and Salvo Montalbano. Elettra Zorzi certainly loves finding out information and getting back at her annoying boss behind the scenes.
And as the second book in the Hanne Wilhemsen series — Blessed Are Those Who Thirst — shows, here is a detective who loves to solve crimes, staying up all night reading documents, sifting through evidence, pursuing suspects.
Kathy – Thank you. I’d love to visit Corinna Chapman’s bakery; ;I’ll bet it would be wonderful there. But yes, I could do without the calories. And you’re right that there are a lot of fictional detectives (e.g. Warshawski, Brunetti, Montalbano) who really do love to solve mysteries. Their passion is their work. They have other things in their lives (especially Brunetti) but they love what they do.
In the origina Jonathan Gashl novels, Lovejoy loves antiques to the point of madness. He is prepared to starve himself in order to be able to afford them, living on fried bread and cheap cakes in order to survive. Other people are unable to understand that this passion is all consuming. He does want money, but only so that he can buy more antiques. This sort of obsession can also lead to crime, and very definitely on the other side of the law is the James Bond villain Auric Goldfinger. His desire for gold drives him to try and commit the crime of the century, where the likely deaths that he will cause merely part of collateral damage
Skywatcher – You’re quite right about Lovejoy. He absolutely loves antiques and that’s behind both his obsession for them and his deep knowledge about them. It’s part of what makes his character so interesting I think. And I’m glad you brought up what you could call ‘the other side of the coin’ when it comes to that sort of love. Obsession can push people too far and Goldfinger is a good example of that.
One of the reasons I like the Dick Francis novels is that there is always someone doing something they love at the heart of it – being a jockey or a banker or a painter or a driver – the “what” doesn’t matter really because he writes the characters in a way that enables that passion to be transmitted to the reader and not in a boring, lecturing kind of way.
Bernadette – That was part of Dick Francis’ gift I think. He had a way of getting the reader interested in the characters and part of that is their love of what they do. I hadn’t thought about that but you’re right. That quality gives his characters an extra layer of life.
Margot: Harry Bosch so loves being a detective he un-retired to return to the LAPD. You can see in he last two books how much he is dreading forced retirement in about 3 years.
Zack Shreeve, the lawyer husband of Joanne Kilbourn (Gail Bowen) clearly loves going to court. He has a zest for the law.
Bill – You are right about Harry Bosch. He loves what he does so much that he can’t really imagine himself doing anything else. Little wonder he’s so anxious about retirement. And I’m also glad you mentioned Zack Shreve. He gets so animated when he’s preparing his cases and he does indeed love going to court. Little wonder he’s a formidable opponent.
definitely feeling the love here, as Les says – and happy belated Valentine’s Day Margot.
Sergio – Thank you – and a belated Happy Valentine’s Day to you, too.
Margot: Might all of us crime fiction bloggers qualify as persons who love mysteries, sometimes too much I dare say.
Bill – Now that is a very good question! I think people who are passionate about reading mysteries really do love what they do. Hmmmm…food for thought, for which thanks.
Great post and perfect for valentine’s day. And as my comment it a few days late, all I will say is that a lot of the wonderful crime fiction blogs (and other book blogs) are written by people with a clear passion for the subject. And how wonderful that books can inspire such passion in people.
Sarah – Thank you! And I couldn’t agree with you more about books and blogs. I love it that books can inspire the passion it takes to put together excellent blogs like yours, in spite of the fact that people are busy, have full-time jobs and families and so on. That takes real passion.
I’m so glad you mentioned The Hollow – very real people with very real lives and real passions. There are characters with real love for their childhood homes in it, for places they visit. People often dismiss Christie as writing puzzles, wtih chesspieces for characters, no real depth, and this is one of the books I would offer as evidence that that’s not so… (I think this is a subject we agree on!)
Moira – Yes, I think it is. The Hollow really does show Christie’s ability to draw characters with some depth and backstory. And I really do like her portrayal of the dedication both Christow and Savernake have for what they do. You’re right too that this novel also shows how people can be deeply attached to a place (Must do a post about that at some point!). It’s interesting too that she experiments here with Poirot coming into the story much later in the action than he usually does in terms of actually investigating.