In The Spotlight: Michael Stanley’s A Carrion Death

SpotlightHello, All,

Welcome to another edition of In The Spotlight. Today we have a two-for-one special on here at Confessions of Mystery Novelist... Writing team Michael Sears and Stanley Trollip write their David ‘Kubu’ Bengu series as Michael Stanley and through it, give readers an authentic look at life in modern-day Botswana. To show you what I mean, let’s turn the spotlight on the first in their Kubu series, A Carrion Death.

The story begins at rural Dale’s Camp, when assistant camp manager and ranger Andries Botha escorts Professor of Ecology Bengani Sibisi on a short research trip. To their shock, the men discover the remains of an unknown man. Hyenas have gotten there first, so there’s not much left by which they can really identify the man. Botswana CID Assistant Director David ‘Kubu’ Bengu is called to take the details of the discovery and launch an investigation. At first it doesn’t seem like much of an investigation is needed, short of identifying the man. The most likely explanation is that the man wandered off too far and was attacked by animals. But soon enough, forensics evidence suggests that the man’s death might have been murder.

That evidence shows that the man was brought to the remote area where he was found by a vehicle that may have belonged to the Botswana Cattle and Mining Company (BCMC). If that’s true, then someone associated with the company may be connected with the victim’s death. Kubu already knows about BCMC, since he knows Angus Hofmeyr, who will gain control of the company on his thirtieth birthday.

The company is considered very important to Botswana’s development, and the directors have friends in the highest places. So Kubu and his boss Jacob Mabaku know that it will be very risky to insinuate anything negative about BCMC or its employees. Nonetheless, all of the trails in this case continue to lead back to this firm. For instance, there’s the murder of a man who was a business associate of current Chair of the Board Cecil Hofmeyr. And there’s another death, also with possible company connections.

As Kubu and his team untangle this case, they uncover several company secrets. They also learn that the murders can all be traced to one source. In the end, the murders have their roots in past history, psychology and the wish for power.

In some important ways, this is a police procedural. So readers follow along as Kubu and his team members gather and make sense of the evidence, interview people, and work with colleagues in South Africa and Angola to find out the truth. That aspect – the international cooperation – adds an interesting dimension to the police work involved in solving certain crimes.

This is a distinctly Botswana story, and it’s not necessarily the gentle Botswana that fans of Alexander McCall Smith’s No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency series know. The country is difficult and dangerous, especially if you don’t know what you’re doing. And in some cases, it’s a violent place. And yet, it’s got a great deal of unique natural beauty. Here’s what Kubu’s thoughts are:


‘When he got to the CID headquarters, he discovered that the baboons had come down from Kgale Hill and were clambering all over the buildings. They were climbing on the wall around the complex, rummaging in the gardens, and even balancing on the edges of the metal barrels holding water at the neighboring building site. Kubu liked the baboons. They cheered him up. Where else, he thought with satisfaction, would you find the CID headquarters of a respected police force used as a Sunday playground for baboons?’


Throughout the novel, we get a strong sense of the culture of Botswana too. There’s even an interesting plot thread that involves the balance between modern science and learning and traditional witch doctor lore and ancient beliefs. There’s also an interesting look at the Botswana mining industry as well as a peek at the international diamond business.

This is the start of a series, and Sears and Trollip lay the groundwork with a cast of characters who fit the context. There’s CID Director Mabaku, who has to balance catching criminals with the political realities of dealing with highly-placed people. He’s irascible at times, and not shy about dressing down his subordinates. But as Kubu reflects, he does the right thing. He’s not at all a stereotypical ‘horrible boss,’ or sycophantic politics-player. There’s also Joy, Kubu’s beloved wife. In some ways she’s a traditional Botswana wife. But she is distinctly her own person, and it’s quite clear that her husband respects her and tries to listen to what she says. There are other characters too who add layers of interest to the story.

And then there’s the character of Kubu himself. His nickname means ‘hippopotamus’ in Setswana, and the name suits him. He’s large (and he does enjoy his food and wine). He’s a bit slow-moving (‘though not lazy). And he seems lumbering on the surface. But anyone who knows about hippos knows that they are not to be underestimated and that’s true of Kubu. He is observant and he’s been taught to really see things and let them speak to him, if I may put it that way. In fact he’s very respectful of traditional ways of knowing and seeing, and in some cases observant of traditional Botswana customs. He’s tenacious, too, and not afraid to take risks. It’s not hard to be on his side as he goes up against some very vicious and dangerous people.

And there is vicious violence in this novel. There are some extremely nasty characters in the story and they do not hesitate to kill. Readers who prefer quieter novels where there is perhaps only one, ‘offstage’ murder will want to know that there are several deaths in this novel. And they’re not all ‘offstage.’ That said though, the violence is not depicted in a lot of detail, and the authors are not gratuitous (at least not in my opinion, so feel free to differ with me if you do).

The mystery itself is held together logically and has a credible explanation. That said though, there are several threads to it, so readers will want to pay close attention. There is also a cast of characters, so readers will be glad to know that there’s a helpful character ‘cheat sheet’ at the front of the novel.

A Carrion Death is a unique kind of police procedural set in a distinctive and compelling setting. It features an appealing protagonist and a fascinating look at Botswana. But what’s your view? Have you read A Carrion Death? If you have, what elements do you see in it?



Coming Up On In The Spotlight


Monday 11 November/Tuesday 12 November – Once Upon a Lie – Jill Paterson

Monday 18 November/Tuesday 19 November – Line of Sight – David Whish-Wilson

Monday 25 November/Tuesday 26 November – The Chalk Circle Man – Fred Vargas


Filed under A Carrion Death, Michael Sears, Michael Stanley, Stanley Trollip

18 responses to “In The Spotlight: Michael Stanley’s A Carrion Death

  1. I so look forward to reading ‘Death of the Mantis’ by the same author (team) – that will be my Africa contribution to the Global Reading Challenge. I’ve had it on my e-reader for quite a while now, but had to give priority to other books. Reading for reviewing vs. reading for pleasure – a whole blog post to be written about that someday. Not that the ones I read for reviewing aren’t pleasurable, but it feels so good to be able to escape and relax for a while.

    • Marina Sofia – I hope you’ll like Death of the Mantis. In my opinion this is a very well-written series with some strong characters and a good solid look at modern Botswana. And that means there are of course both good things and very unpleasant things too. The atmosphere and setting are very well done I think. I hope you’ll get to read it soon.

  2. That does sound interesting – we are all much more Botswana-aware since Alexander McCall Smith came on the scene. I’m torn because I love the idea of a mystery set there, but the violence is offputting. Still, a very helpful review (as always) Margot.

    • Moira – Thanks for the kind words. You’re absolutely right that ever since the McCall Smith series, we’ve known more than we ever had about Botswana. And interestingly enough, this novel does have some of the same cultural reality that that series does. It is more violent, although I wouldn’t say gratuitous. If you do get the chance to give it a try, I hope you’ll like it.

  3. Definitely planning to read this book, I have the first two in the series. It will be sometime in 2014 I hope. Nice overview, Margot. I don’t think I would have been expecting the violence, but don’t know why I should be surprised.

    • Tracy – Thanks for the kind words. I do hope you’ll get the chance to read this one and of course, that you’ll enjoy it. I think it’s a compelling picture of life in modern Botswana. There is more violence than there is in the Alexander McCall Smith series, but I don’t think it’s overblown, and I honestly think Kubu is as upset by it as anyone would be.

  4. Love McCall Smith’s books, they are wonderful. However, I would not be shocked by the violence in the Michael Stanley books because our news reels here are full of what is/was going on over there and throughout Africa over many years. It is a sad fact of life and McCall Smith’s stories have shown a different side which I found refreshing. I have not read any Stanley books but would not be put off, especially after such a fab review.

    • Jane – I’m very fond of McCall Smith’s books too, but as you say, one can’t get away from the fact that there’s a lot of violence in that part of Africa. The Micheal Stanley books are honest about that, but I have to also say that the violence is not described in gory detail or dwelt upon if I can put it that way. It is definitely real though.

  5. Sounds like a really interesting one, and the contrast with McCall Smith’s Botswana would add an extra layer. Thanks as always, Margot, for highlighting books that maybe would pass under the radar otherwise. 🙂

    • FictionFan – Glad you enjoyed the post. And you put that very well about the contrast with the McCall Smith series. For people who do want to understand life in Botswana, this series does broaden/deepen one’s understanding. In some ways it’s quite similar to the McCall Smith series, because the authors have all made sure to be authentic. But it’s different enough that you do get a bigger picture if I can put it that way.

  6. Michael Stanley are a very good writing duo and I’m really glad you’ve covered this one.

  7. Katy McCoy

    I liked A Carrion Death. It was a classic type of mystery, transferred to a place that was new and interesting. I could never get into the McCall Smith series so Botswana was relatively new to me. The violence was not off-putting to me. I was more “bothered” by the attitudes of violence in John Burdett’s Bangkok 8. While I will read one more mystery by Burdett with trepidation, I’m looking forward to the next Stanley book.

    • Katy – I’m glad you enjoyed the novel. I like the way you put that: a classic-type mystery but in a different context. I think that’s a really accurate way to describe. In my opinion, the difference between the violence in this one and the violence in the Burdett novels might be the casual attitude towards it in the latter. That’s hard on me too.

  8. Col

    Interesting, but as I’m trying to avoid more on the pile, I will pass regretfully!

  9. I can say with certainty that I haven’t read a mystery set in Botswana. Thanks for the review.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s