Well I’ll Be Loyal to You in Every Way*

Loyalty1One of the more valuable qualities humans can have is arguably loyalty. If we can’t count on loyalty from family, friends, co-workers and so on, then it’s easy to start wondering whether we can really trust anyone. And that’s unsettling, to say the least. Of course, like most things about humans, loyalty is a proverbial double-edged sword. Loyalty can be an important part of simple safety and security. On the other hand, loyalty can be tragically misguided. It’s an important aspect of human interaction though, so it’s no wonder that we see it in crime fiction.

Agatha Christie addresses loyalty in several of her stories. I’ll just mention one example. In Murder on the Orient Express, Hercule Poirot travels across Europe on the world-famous Orient Express train. On the second night of the journey, fellow passenger Samuel Ratchett is stabbed to death. Poirot is persuaded to investigate and try to find out who the killer is before the train is stopped at the next border. That way, the solution (and presumably, the killer) can be handed over to the police. Poirot has a limited number of suspects since the only possibilities are the other passengers in the same car as Ratchett. As Poirot interviews the passengers and gets to know the background of the case, we learn that loyalty plays an important role in this mystery. Here is what one passenger, Princess Natalia Dragomiroff, says about it:


‘I believe, Messieurs, in loyalty – to one’s friends and one’s family and one’s caste.’


And as the story evolves, we see how much loyalty determines what people do and say.

A bright thread of loyalty adds much to Wendy James’ The Mistake. In that novel, we meet Jodie Evans Garrow, who seems to have the perfect life. She’s married to a successful attorney, she’s got two healthy children, and her own life seems content and ordered. Then her daughter Hannah is involved in a traffic accident and is taken to a Sydney hospital. It turns out it’s the same hospital where years earlier, Jodie gave birth to another child Elsa Mary – a child she’s never told anyone about, not even her husband. A nurse at the hospital remembers Jodie from that other time and asks about the baby. Jodie says she gave the child up for adoption, but when the overly curious nurse does some checking, she finds no records of an adoption. That’s when the questions and later the accusations begin. What happened to Elsa Mary? If she’s alive, where is she? If not, did Jodie have something to do with her death? It’s not long before Jodie becomes a social pariah, with everyone she thought was in her circle turned against her. Then one night, Jodie is invited to a book club gathering. The gathering itself is a disaster, but through it Jodie is re-united with an old friend Bridget ‘Bridie’ Sullivan. The two were very close when they were younger but hadn’t seen each other in years. When they re-establish their friendship, Jodie finds that Bridie is truly loyal to her. And that loyalty proves to be a real source of solace.

Martin Clark’s The Legal Limit also has a theme of loyalty.  In that novel, brothers Mason and Gates Hunt come from an abusive and unhappy background. But they’ve dealt with it in very different ways. Mason has made the most of every opportunity he’s gotten and has become a lawyer. Gates on the other hand has squandered his considerable athletic ability and now lives on money he gets from his mother and from his girlfriend’s Welfare payments. Then one day, Gates has an argument with his romantic rival Wayne Thompson. Later that night, the Hunt brothers are coming home from a night out when they encounter Thompson again. Before anyone really knows what’s happened, Gates has shot his rival. Out of a sense of loyalty to his brother, Mason helps cover up the crime. Years later that loyalty comes back to haunt him when Gates is arrested for cocaine trafficking. He begs Mason, who’s now a Commonwealth of Virginia prosecutor, to help get him out of prison, but Mason refuses. Gates then threatens to implicate his brother in the still-unsolved murder of Wayne Thompson unless he co-operates. When Mason calls his Gates’ bluff, Gates makes good on his threat. Now Mason is indicted for murder and has to find the best way he can to clear his name. When this happens, we see the positive side of loyalty as Mason learns just how loyal his deputy prosecutor Custis Norman is to him.

Y.A. Erskine’s The Brotherhood explores loyalty within the police force. One tragic morning, Sergeant John White of the Tasmania Police Force is stabbed when he and probationer Lucy Howard investigate a home invasion. The most likely suspect is seventeen-year-old Darren Rowley, who comes from a poor neighbourhood of Hobart and who’s been in trouble with the law more than once. As the police look into this case, some evidence turns up that suggests that White may not have been the sterling cop everyone thinks he was. And one of the plot threads in this novel is the way in which the other police rally round his memory out of a sense of loyalty to him and to the police.

Andrew Nette’s Ghost Money introduces us to Australian ex-cop Max Quinlan. He’s turned out to be fairly good at finding people who don’t want to be found, which is part of the reason Madeleine Avery hires him to find her brother Charles. Charles Avery’s last known residence was Bangkok, so Quinlan starts his search there. When he gets to Quinlan’s apartment, he finds the body of Avery’s business partner Robert Lee. He also finds evidence that Avery has gone to Cambodia, so he decides to pick up the trail there. In Phnom Penh, Quinlan meets journalist’s assistant Heng Sarin. He also finds out that there are several ruthless and very dangerous people who don’t want him asking any questions. Gradually though, Quinlan finds out that Avery went to Northern Cambodia, so he decides to follow that lead, and that’s where the answers to the mystery turn out to be. Through it all, Sarin proves to be a very loyal friend and colleague. The two go through some frightening situations together but Sarin remains a steadfast companion.

Loyalty is also a theme in Mark Douglas-Home’s The Sea Detective. Two young girls Preeti and Basanti have become part of the dhanda – a term used to refer to India’s sex trade. The girls’ families were paid money for their services with the idea that the girls will work in the trade for a certain amount of time and then return to their villages. Preeti and Basanti are taken to Scotland together to meet client demand there. On the trip, they become close friends and promise to be loyal to each other. They’re separated soon after their arrival though, and Basanti doesn’t know what’s happened to her friend. So as soon as she can, she escapes from the people who’ve been holding her and goes in search of Preeti. That’s when she discovers that the body of an unknown girl has been found in the sea and that it’s most likely the body of her friend. Basanti finds out that Ph.D. student Caladh ‘Clad’ McGill is also interested in the body. He’s an oceanographer who’s an expert in tides and water-based movement so he may be able to help Basanti find out how Preeti’s body ended up where it was found McGill and Basanti form an unlikely and strange kind of partnership and together, they find out what happened to Preeti. Throughout that thread of this novel, we see how Basanti’s loyalty to her friend has kept her strong throughout everything that’s happened to her, and how it motivates her to find Preeti’s killers.

There are, of course, a lot of other examples of loyalty and the role it plays in what we do. And I haven’t even touched on the myriad examples of sleuths and partners who are loyal to each other – too easy…


ps. Oh, the ‘photo? I rarely see an expression of loyalty quite like a dog eagerly watching and waiting for the human it owns…



*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Brendan Benson’s The Pledge.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Andrew Nette, Mark Douglas-Home, Martin Clark, Wendy James, Y.A. Erskine

10 responses to “Well I’ll Be Loyal to You in Every Way*

  1. What a lovely dog in that photo!

    Because I read so many police procedurals, I notice how often loyalty between partners or other police officers shows up in mysteries and how much better things work when there is trust and loyalty. In one of my recent reads, Dead Before Dying by Deon Meyer, the policemen are working in a relationship with a new boss who makes lots of demands, but within the group they are loyal and supportive to each other. In Kaleidoscope by J. Robert Janes, set in occupied France in WWII, the partners are on different sides (a French policeman working with a Gestapo officer) but have developed a loyal relationship. Which can be difficult because of the demands of their superiors.

    • Tracy – You bring up such a well-taken point about loyalty between police partners. It’s a very special kind of loyalty and it’s so important to an investigation. I think part of it is that police partners have to depend on each other for their lives, at least at times. That makes that bond very important. I agree with you that Meyer depicts that partnership very effectively. I’ll confess I’ve not yet read the James, ‘though I’ve heard good things about it. But that’s exactly the kind of thing I mean. We also see that loyalty in Fred Vargas’ Adamsberg novels. He and his team may have their eccentricities, even disagreements at times. But he is loyal to his teammates and they to him. And that makes all the difference.
      Oh, and I’ll pass along your compliment to Mr. Metoo. It won’t be good at all for his ego, though… 😉

  2. kathy d.

    First things first, adorable dog, and his loyalty never wavers, I’d imagine.
    I love the character of Bridie in Wendy James’ The Mistake, wonderful when a child, and loyal and kind as an adult.
    The Sea Detective, while not always a seamless convergence of two plot lines, does portray steadfast loyalty between two friends, a good characteristic of this book.
    And, yes, how Commissaire Adamsberg’s team works well together and collaborates. They also know each other’s strengths, weakness and foibles. And they’re loyal to the nth degree. A scene in a bathroom in one book (not mention , to avoid spoilers) shows one detective helping another escape a police investigation in another country; it’s hilarious while it shows loyalty.

    • Kathy – Thanks for the kind words, and yes, Mr. Metoo is extremely loyal. And you’re quite right about Bridie Sullivan. She’s a terrific character I think, and she does prove loyal when Jodie really needs her. As to The Sea Detective, the loyalty between Preeti and Basanti really forms a solid and strong thread in the story And as for Commissaire Adamsberg and his team, that loyalty among the team members is one of the great things about that great series.

  3. Margot: In A Loyal Character Dancer by Qiu Xiaolong the author uses the only acceptable dance during the Cultural Revolution, the Loyal Character Dance, to invoke subtle issues of loyalty for Inspector Chen – to the Communist Party, to family, to the police service, to a visiting American Marshal. It also happens to be an excellent mystery.

    • Bill – That is a fascinating way to look at (and express) loyalty. And of course, maintaining loyalty is of paramount importance in that context. Thanks for reminding me of that novel.

  4. Another great topic, Margot. My mind flew straight to an example of misguided loyalty in a recent read by Anne Holt, Death of The Demon. In this novel, one member of staff’s decision to cover up for another at the Spring Sunshine Foster Home has tragic consequences — and may be behind the stabbing death of its director Agnes Vestavik.

    But the most moving example of loyalty I’ve ever read in crime fiction is between the two young girls, Sadie Green and Gwen Hubble, who go missing together in Carol O’Connell’s The Judas Child. In this case, the children’s loyalty to each other is a matter of life or death — or rather, life and death.

    • Angela – Thank you. And thanks for mentioning the Anne Holt series. I like her Hanne Wilhelmsen character quite a lot. And that novel highlights how sometimes loyalty to a colleague can indeed be sadly misguided… I’ve read some Carol O’Connell too, but not (yet) that one. It really seems a clear example though of exactly what I had in mind with this post.

  5. I’m going to mention a film: the Sherlock Holmes / Ripper pastiche Murder by Decree. It’s a marvellous film, with an amazing cast – Christopher Plummer, Donald Sutherland, James Mason – and tremendously involving. Towards the end Holmes gives a touching tribute to the mutual loyalty of a group of women, key to the plot, a group of women who wouldn’t otherwise get much praise. I love this film, and don’t know why it isn’t better-known and remembered – it is certainly one of the very best Holmes productions not based on the original canon, with some marvellous acting.

    • Moira – I think that’s a great contribution! I’ll confess I’ve not seen the film, ‘though I’ve heard good things about it. But from what I know it’s a perfect example of the kind of loyalty I had in mind. And I’m not surprised the acting’s good; that’s a fine cast.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s