A Box of Chocolates and a Dozen Flowers*

Valentine's Day 2014 It’s St. Valentine’s Day as I write this post. Now, traditionally, Valentine’s Day is supposed to be a day of grand romantic gestures such as flowers, candy and so on, and that’s all fine. But are you aware of how dangerous those things can be? Before you go rushing out to buy that special box of luxury chocolates or that bouquet of expensive roses, have a quick look at some crime fiction and you’ll see what I mean.




Flowers are beautiful of course, and if you watch advertisements, you’ll be convinced that nothing says ‘love’ like roses. But consider how dangerous flowers can be. In Agatha Christie’s story The Blue Geranium, a group of people including Miss Marple go to dinner at the home of Colonel Arthur Bantry and his wife Dolly. During the meal, Bantry tells the story of George Pritchard, whose wife suddenly died of what seems to have been shock and fear. That’s not surprising, since she wasn’t in good physical or mental health. In fact, she began to believe that she could only be helped by psychics and seers. That’s how she fell under the influence of Zarida, Psychic Reader of the Future. Zarida specifically told Mrs. Pritchard to beware of, among other things, blue geraniums, blue primroses and blue hollyhocks. Then, mysteriously, the flowers on the wallpaper in Mrs. Pritchard’s bedroom began to turn blue. That’s when she suddenly died. Some people believed that Zarida actually predicted the future. Others blamed Pritchard for killing his wife. But Miss Marple has quite a different explanation.

In Rex Stout’s novella Door to Death, Nero Wolfe takes the drastic step of leaving his brownstone when his usual orchid expert Theodore Horstmann takes a leave of absence. Wolfe has heard of another expert Andrew Krasicki, who works for the Pitccairn family. He wrote to Krasicki asking him to fill in for Horstmann but got no response. Not willing to risk his beloved orchids, Wolfe takes Archie Goodwin with him and they make a personal visit to Krasicki. While they’re there, the body of Krasicki’s fiancée Dini Lauer is discovered behind a canvas in the Pitcairns’ greenhouse. Krasicki’s the most likely suspect since he admits that Dini visited him at the greenhouse the evening before. But he swears he’s innocent. If Wolfe is to bring Krasicki back with him to tend his orchids, he’s going to have to find out who really killed the victim. For Wolfe, that’s quite a motivation. See what trouble flowers can bring you?




It’s also traditional to give a box of candy on Valentine’s Day. Now, far be it from me to discourage you from supporting the chocolate industry. Really. I mean it. But chocolate can be very dangerous stuff.

Just ask Margaret de Rushbridger, who plays a role in Agatha Christie’s Three Act Tragedy (AKA Murder in Three Acts). She is a patient at a Yorkshire sanitarium run by eminent specialist Dr. Bartholomew Strange. One night, Strange suddenly dies of what turns out to be nicotine poisoning while he’s hosting a dinner party. Not long afterwards, Margaret de Rushbridger suddenly dies too, this time from chocolates poisoned by nicotine. As you might suspect, there is a connection, but not the one you may think. Hercule Poirot is already investigating Strange’s death and an earlier one that may be related. And in the end he links those deaths to that of Margaret de Rushbridger. See? If she’d just left the chocolates alone, she might have been fine.

And then there’s Anthony Berkeley’s The Poisoned Chocolates Case. Berkeley’s sleuth Roger Sheringham runs the Crimes Circle, a discussion club for those interested in crimes and their solutions. When DCI Moresby is invited to address the clue, he presents them with a fascinating case. Well-known chocolate company Mason & Sons has come out with a new variety of chocolates. As a way of garnering interest (and of course, sales), they’ve sent boxes of chocolates out to some select influential people. One of them is Sir Eustace Pennefeather Pennefeather doesn’t eat chocolate, so he passes the candy on to a fellow member of his club Graham Bendix. Bendix in turn takes the chocolate home to share with his wife Joan. Shortly thereafter, both Bendixes are sickened. Graham recovers but Joan does not. Analysis shows that the chocolates were poisoned. Moresby lays the case before the Crimes Circle and in turn, each member presents a theory of who killed Joan Bendix and why. The answer isn’t what you’d think, but it does go to show that chocolate is risky.




Very well, then, what about a bottle of fine wine? What a lovely romantic touch, right? Not so fast. Do you know how many fictional characters have been poisoned by wine?

In Colin Dexter’s The Silent World of Nicholas Quinn, Inspector Morse and Sergeant Lewis investigate the murder of Nicholas Quinn, the newest member of Oxford’s Foreign Examinations Syndicate. That’s a high-status position, as the Syndicate oversees all exams given in non-UK countries with a UK education tradition. One afternoon, Quinn is murdered with poisoned sherry and Morse and Lewis are soon on the case. It turns out that there are several suspects too. For one thing, Quinn was not a unanimous choice for the Syndicate, so the members who didn’t want him there are under suspicion. Then too, it turns out that some Syndicate members are keeping secrets that Quinn could easily have found out. In the end, Morse and Lewis track down the culprit, but it all might have been avoided if Quinn hadn’t had that sherry. I’m just saying…

And then there’s Arlette Montrose Banfield, who features in Emily Brightwell’s Victorian-Era historical novel  Mrs. Jeffries Forges Ahead. Arlette and her husband Lewis are welcoming guests to the Banfield family’s annual Ball. Everyone takes seats and soon the wine begins to flow. Suddenly Arlette dies of what turns out to be poisoned champagne. Inspector Gerald Witherspoon takes the case and he gets to work right away since the Banfield family are ‘people who matter.’ It took timing and daring, but someone managed to poison the victim in the full view of lots of witnesses. Witherspoon’s ever-efficient and capable housekeeper Mrs. Jeffries alerts her staff, and each in a different way, they help solve the case.

See what I mean? Those grand gestures can be deadly. Besides, they can be expensive. And anyway, there are lots of other great ways to show you care. Just ask Kerry Greenwood’s Corinna Chapman. She knows her lover Daniel Cohen truly cares about her. He brings her coffee in the morning. Bliss. And then there’s Louise Penny’s Armand Gamache. There’s no doubt his wife Reine-Marie loves him, and one of the ways she shows it is by helping him sort through his files and keep them organised. Now that’s an act of love. And of course there’s my personal choice for truly Great. Romantic. Gesture. Read Angela Savage’s The Half Child. Well, read it anyway, but there’s a great scene in it. Trust me.  You’re welcome. Always happy to help with romantic advice. 😉




*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from The Bird and The Bee’s My Fair Lady.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Angela Savage, Anthony Berkeley, Colin Dexter, Emily Brightwell, Kerry Greenwood, Louise Penny, Rex Stout

29 responses to “A Box of Chocolates and a Dozen Flowers*

  1. I think you’ve covered most of the bases here, Margot, although I’d add that – in or out of context – I would have to describe the ending of “The Poisoned Chocolates Case” as delicious…

  2. Love your take on these items, Margot. 🙂 What about the hazards of taking your loved one to a quite country inn for a romantic getaway or on a cruise? I always see stories in a different light after reading your post. Hope you’re having a wonderful (and safe) Valentine’s Day!

    • Mason – Thanks for the kind words. And you’re absolutely right about those romantic getaways! Country inns, cruises, posh hotels, all of them can be hazardous. Glad you added that public-safety alert! 😉
      Happy Valentine’s Day to you, too!

  3. Fantastic post Margot, love it. At least the gift I received was for detecting crime, thank goodness it wasn’t chocolate!

  4. Thanks for that Margot – and I hope you have a lovely day.

  5. kathy d.

    Well, I think on Valentine’s Day, one must take the risk and receive flowers and chocolates, no matter what the possible dangers could be! Chocolate is a must-have on this day and flowers are such a beautiful gift.
    I’m indulging in fudge, tea and a good book, maybe a dvd.

    • Kathy – Valentine’s Day is the perfect day for indulging in fudge and a good book. Of course, every day is a good day to read. And it is hard to say, ‘No,’ to chocolate and flowers isn’t it???

  6. Margot: In Murder at the Mendel by Gail Bowen there is a murder at a gala banquet when a character is successfully poisoned because an antidote was hidden away. Formal dinners can be dangerous for more reasons than terminal boredom.

    Since you take your own photos are those lovely roses a gift from Mr. Confessions or a not so subtle hint to him on what he needed to buy this afternoon?

    • Bill – You have a very well-taken point about formal dinners. As romantic as it’s supposed to be to dress up and go to such events, they can be deadly. Your example of that’s excellent and there are lots of others too. I ought to do a post about just that some time.
      And about the flowers? No, they’re not from Mr. Confessions…. I saw them at a market and thought they were too beautiful not to share. But fear not. Mr. Confessions… didn’t need any hints. We went out for a lovely dinner – with no poisoning. 😉

  7. In Margery Allingham’s Death of a Ghost, Mr Campion drinks some wine which has a very strange effect on him indeed – I think it’s something she invented.
    For a romantic gesture (not Valentine related) I have always loved the Cinderella scenario in Christie’s Moving Finger where hero Jerry drags Megan onto the train and takes her up to London for an unexpected makeover. I was a teenager when I first read it, and thought it was the most amazing thing that could happen – now I’m too old for that idea but still find it quite charming.

    • Moira – It really is a charming gesture and romantic, even if it doesn’t happen in Valentine’s Day. And I don’t think one’s ever too old to appreciate it when someone cares about someone else. Thanks too for the mention of Death of a Ghost. Not only is it a great example, but it’s a good reminder that I’ve not read ALlingham lately. Time to rectify that.

  8. If ya gotta go, then poisoning via chocolates would be so much more fun than most of the alternatives…

  9. kathy d.

    Yes, death by chocolate is preferable to most of the usual methods.

  10. Well aren’t you the bringer of all that’s romantic! 😉

  11. kathy d.

    My conclusion at the end of the two-day chocolate fest here is that there are obvious murder methods involved in this holiday, other than poisoning in the wine — severe allergies to roses, causing anaphylactic shock, and death by overeating chocolate.
    Yes! That may be my undoing — a good book, lots of tea and endless kahlua-walnut fudge. Death by chocolate overdose! A new, yet possible cause of death.

    • Kathy – You have a creative mind when it comes to murder methods! Those could definitely be effective. And a weekend with good reading, fudge and tea sounds terrific – minus the real-life murder, of course.

  12. I think I bring this up every time you mention candy or chocolates, but in Rex Stout’s The Red Box, Nero Wolfe solves a crime related to murder by poisoning some candy. It is one of my favorites in the series.

  13. Col

    Not familiar with any of your examples – and in truth they aren’t singing out to me to be read

  14. Pingback: Love and bullets – Classic crime in the blogosphere: February 2014 | Past Offences Classic Crime Fiction

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s