It’s No Good, There’s No Way Out*

CorneredIn Agatha Christie’s The Hollow, Hercule Poirot investigates the shooting death of Harley Street specialist Dr. John Christow, who was spending the weekend at the country home of Sir Henry and Lady Lucy Angkatell when he was killed. The case seems very clear-cut at first. As Christie fans will know, though, things aren’t exactly as they appear to be. At one point, Poirot is discussing the actions of one particular character. Here’s what he says:

‘Have you not seen a dog caught in a trap-it sets its teeth into anyone who touches it.’

He has a point. When people (and other animals) feel cornered, they often strike out. That instinct for self-preservation is very strong. Certainly the character to whom Poirot is referring does that; other crime-fictional characters do, too.

For instance, in Tony Hillerman’s The Ghostway, Jim Chee of the Navajo Tribal Police is assigned to find sixteen-year-old Margaret Billie Sosi, who has gone missing from the school she attends. Her disappearance turns out to be connected to the murder of a distant kinsman Albert Gorman. A Los Angeles Navajo, Gorman had moved to the Reservation not very long before he was killed. Chee tracks Sosi to Los Angeles, but she disappears again. When Chee learns what, exactly, links the missing teenager to the murder, he finds out the truth about both. As he does, we see the effect that feeling cornered has on Sosi. I can say without spoiling the novel that she’s not a ‘demon seed’ ‘baddie.’ But like anyone else, she has an instinct to stay alive.

That same instinct is woven into Walter Mosley’s A Red Death. In that story, Ezekiel ‘Easy’ Rawlins gets a threatening letter from IRS agent Reginald Lawrence. The letter claims that Rawlins owes thousands of dollars to the agency; if he doesn’t pay, he’ll be imprisoned. Rawlins knows that he can’t pay the debt, and prepares to go to jail. Then, a solution comes in the form of FBI agent Darrell Craxton. Craxton wants Rawlins to help bring down suspected communist Chaim Wentzler. In return, Craxton will make those tax problems go away. Seeing no other choice, Rawlins reluctantly agrees. As he gets to know Wentzler, he forms a friendship with the man and becomes less and less inclined to be a part of Craxton’s plans. Then, one of the other residents in Rawlins’ apartment building apparently commits suicide. And there are two other deaths, both clearly murders. Rawlins is innocent, but he was present at both crime scenes, so the LAPD have him in their sights. At the same time, he’s doing his best to resolve his dilemma about Chaim Wentzler. Feeling very much cornered, Rawlins does what he feels he has to do to deal with both issues.

In one plot thread of Lene Kaaberbøl and Agnete Friis’ Death of a Nightingale, Natasha Doroshenko flees the Ukraine with her daughter Katerina after the murder of Natasha’s husband Pavel. He was a controversial journalist whose stories had angered the wrong people. At first, Natasha thinks she and her daughter have found safety in Denmark. She even falls in love again with Michael Vestergaard. Then, everything changes. Natasha is imprisoned for attempting to murder her fiancé. During her time in police custody, she overhears a conversation that convinces her she hasn’t escaped danger from the Ukraine. She manages to elude the police and heads for Coal House Camp, a Red Cross facility where Katerina has been staying. Natasha’s goal is to retrieve her daughter and flee again. As she tries to do so, we see the effect of feeling cornered on the choices she makes and the things she does.

There are also examples of what people do when they feel cornered in Geoffrey McGeachin’s The Digger’s Rest Hotel. It’s 1947, and Melbourne cop Charlie Berlin has recently returned from harrowing service in World War II. He’s seconded to the town of Wodonga, where the local police are dealing with a series of robberies committed by a motorcycle gang. The most recent one has ended in serious injury, so there’s a lot of pressure to solve these crimes as quickly as possible. In the process of working this case, Berlin gets involved in another: the body of fifteen-year-old Jenny Lee has been found in an alley. At first, Berlin thinks that her death is connected with the robberies. But he learns that the motorcycle gang was not involved. Now he has to find out the truth about both cases. And I can say without spoiling the story that that sense of feeling cornered, with no way out, plays an important role.

It does in Honey Brown’s Through the Cracks, too. Fourteen-year-old Adam Vander has finally managed to escape his abusive father, Joe. But Adam’s been so kept away from the world that he’s completely unprepared for life ‘on the outside.’ This makes him extremely vulnerable. He finds a protector in Billy Benson, a young man who visits the house just as Adam’s preparing to make his escape. Billy takes Adam under his wing, as the saying goes, and helps him with basics like a place to stay, clothes and food. During the week they spend together, the two become friends. They also get mixed up in some very real danger that threatens both of them. As the story goes on, Adam and Billy have to face some very unsettling truths about themselves and their pasts. And throughout the novel, the suspense is built as both of them react to both the danger and those truths. In more than one place, that sense of being cornered plays an important role in what they do.

When people believe they’re trapped, the instinct to stay alive sometimes takes over, as it does when any animal senses that it’s cornered. And the impact of that feeling can make for a solid layer of tension in a novel. Which ones have stayed with you?



*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Jeff Lynne’s No Way Out.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Agnete Friis, Geoffrey McGeachin, Honey Brown, Lene Kaaberbøl, Tony Hillerman, Walter Mosley

20 responses to “It’s No Good, There’s No Way Out*

  1. Graham Greene’s Brighton Rock has a chilling picture of the young criminal Pinkie, who goes to terrifying lengths to try to get out from his situation. And I’m glad you mentioned The Hollow – one of my favourite Christies too.

    • Oh, Pinkie is a good example of what I had in mind here, Moira – thanks. And I need to brush up again on my Greene! About The Hollow? Not everyone agrees with me, I know. But I think it’s got some terrific characters, and I do like the way Poirot interacts with them. Lady Lucy is definitely one of a kind…

  2. Good timing Margot – I just finished SLAYGROUND, in which Richard Stark’s antihero Parker is forced literally into a box (well, a square-shaped enclosed out of season fairground) and spends the whole book trying to get out!

  3. I’m thinking of MEMORY by Westlake where a guy loses his memory and has to figure out why the cops are after him.

    • Oh, that’s a fascinating premise, Patti! And of course Westlake has a lot of talent. I’ll admit I’ve not yet read that particular one, but I think I will.

  4. Kathy D.

    Merete in Mercy or The Keeper of Lost Causes. Without a doubt, the character most determined to stay alive and outwit her captors.
    There there’s short-term captivity, as V.I. Warshawski was kept in
    a basement in Critical Mass, but was victorious in the end — of course,
    that series just keeps going as she ages in real time.

  5. Kathy D.

    Well, V.I. got her revenge for the mistreatment.

  6. I think this type of trapped feeling and the desperation related to it is behind the motive for a lot of the second/subsequent murders in mysteries. Someone has seen/heard/pieced something together and either unwisely blackmails or allows the murderer to see that they’re onto him. Provides nice motive for additional crimes.

    • Oh, that’s really true, Elizabeth! The more cornered the criminal feels (i.e. I’m going to be caught!) the more likely s/he is to kill again. In fact, now you’re getting me thinking about second murders in novels – thank you for the ‘food for thought!.’

  7. This is the kind of plot point that one of my favourite thriller writers, Haralna Coben, uses again and again – an ordinary guy put in dangerous circumstances and having to fight to get out. I just finished Coben’s latest book and was thinking he must have used the same basic premise a million times, but always manages to find an original angle. In this latest one, the ordinary guy is approached by a stranger who tells him a secret about his wife and from there on he’s fighting to keep his family safe…

    • Coben does a good job of that, FictionFan, doesn’t he? And I think you’ve hit on something else important too. It really adds to the tension when the person cornered is an ordinary person who was just going about life when everything started. It works really well in noir stories too, or at least the ones I’ve read.

  8. tracybham

    Every time I come here you cover more books that I have been meaning to read. And in the comments too. Very interesting topic, Margot.

  9. Col

    Another great post, Margot. I do need to read the McGeachin book, cheers for the reminder!

  10. Once again you’ve managed to blow my mind with your memory of the books you’ve read. If I haven’t told you lately, you’re amazing, Margot!

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s