I Leave a Big Tip With Every Receipt*

ReceiptsIf you look among your things, you’ll probably see random receipts and cash slips for things. They can clutter up a pocket or handbag. And when it’s something simple like getting fuel, it may seem a waste to get a cash slip. But those little pieces of evidence can be very useful.

Anyone who’s on an expense account or who gets reimbursed can tell you that keeping receipts is important. Detectives use those pieces of information too. A cash slip, newspaper clipping or even a passport stamp can either support or refute what a witness or suspect says. So that kind of ‘paper trail’ can be of real value when the police are investigating a crime, or when a PI is looking into a case. Little wonder then that we see things like receipts and stamps all throughout crime fiction.

Agatha Christie uses these details in more than one of her novels. For instance, in Sad Cypress, Hercule Poirot investigates the poisoning murder of Mary Gerrard. The most likely suspect is Elinor Carlisle, who had more than one motive for murder. In the first place, Elinor’s fiancé Roderick ‘Roddy’ Welman had become smitten with Mary, which ended their engagement. What’s more, Elinor’s very wealthy aunt, Laura Welman, had taken a great interest in Mary, and might very well have altered her will to leave Elinor out of it entirely. Local GP Peter Lord has fallen in love with Elinor and wants her name cleared. So Poirot looks into the matter more deeply. And in the case of one character, he finds that passport stamps put the lie to what that character claimed.

In Colin Dexter’s The Silent World of Nicholas Quinn, Inspector Morse and Sergeant Lewis investigate the poisoning murder of Nicholas Quinn, the only Deaf member of Oxford’s Foreign Exams Syndicate. This group is responsible for overseeing exams given in other countries that follow the British education model. The detectives start with those closest to the victim, and soon find that several members of the Syndicate might have had a good reason to want Quinn dead. For one thing, his appointment to the Syndicate was by no means universally supported. For another, he’d learned some secrets about some of the different members. One aspect of this investigation is finding out where each person was on the afternoon of Quinn’s death. As they piece together what happened that day, Morse and Lewis find that ticket stubs from an adult cinema are very informative.

Donna Leon’s Through a Glass, Darkly is among other things, the story of the death of Giorgio Tassini, night watchman at one of Venice’s glass blowing factories. At first it all looks like a terrible accident. He’d been working independently on a glass project and the evidence suggests that an accident with the oven caused his death. But Commissario Guido Brunetti is not so sure. Tassini had been a very vocal critic of the glass blowing factories’ procedure for getting rid of toxic waste. He claimed that they were illegally dumping it, putting everyone at risk. Brunetti and Ispettore Lorenzo Vianello discover who is responsible for Tassini’s murder, but they’ll find it very hard to prove what they know. Then one evening, Brunetti gets exactly what he needs: a receipt from a canal boat. That piece of paper puts the lie to what the killer said to the police, and allows for an arrest.

The Michael Stanley writing duo introduces us to Botswana police detective David ‘Kubu’ Bengu in A Carrion Death. He is drawn into an investigation when the remains of an unknown man are found on the property of the rural Dale’s Camp. At first, it looks as though the man was attacked by hyenas. But soon enough, forensics tests suggest that he was murdered. Forensics experts also provide a very important clue: a cash slip found by the body. It turns out to be a receipt from the Number One Petrol Station, and for Kubu, that’s a valuable lead. When he follows up on it and finds the station, he learns that the vehicle in question was a Land Rover painted a garish shade of yellow. Such vehicles are owned by the Botswana Cattle and Mining Company (BCMC). And that information puts Kubu on a trail that eventually connects someone associated with that company to this murder and to another that occurs.

There’s also Tess Gerritsen’s Vanish, which follows two major plot threads. In one, Boston medical examiner Dr. Maura Iles discovers to her shock that one of the body bags in the mortuary contains a young woman who’s still alive. Iles gives the alert, and the woman is taken to the nearby hospital. The unidentified woman recovers quickly, and rushes from her hospital room after killing a security guard. Then, she goes to the hospital’s Diagnostic Imaging Department, where she takes a group of people hostage. One of them is Boston police detective Jane Rizzoli, who’s there for a sonogram. The police, a SWAT team, and hostage negotiators now have to figure out what the hostage-taker wants, and how to rescue her captives. In the meantime, the other plot thread concerns seventeen-year-old Mila, who left her home in Belarus, lured by promises of a good job in the US and a better life. To put it mildly, things haven’t worked out as planned. The two plot threads are related, ‘though not as you might think. One of the leads that the police get on this case is a credit card receipt for a fuel purchase. That information helps them to piece together at least part of the mystery.

Receipts and odd pieces of paper might just seem like so much junk. But they can prove absolutely invaluable to detectives. They’re also very useful to attorneys on both sides of a case who want to establish a person’s whereabouts or purchases. That oft-repeated bit of advice about saving receipts is actually fairly solid…


On Another Note…

There’s still time to vote for the Jo Nesbø novel you’d like to see me spotlight. If you’d like to let your voice be heard, check out my poll right here.

*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Billy Joel’s Big Man on Mulberry Street.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Colin Dexter, Donna Leon, Michael Stanley, Tess Gerritsen

29 responses to “I Leave a Big Tip With Every Receipt*

  1. I’m forever losing receipts when I’m travelling on business – I remember one company I invoiced said: ‘You never seem to eat!’ (that’s because I keep forgetting to save the receipts in restaurants and cafes). Nowadays, of course, it’s much easier to trace things via bank cards, but if someone pays cash, or if they pick up someone else’s receipt so as to have an alibi… well, there are still loopholes.

    • Paper receipts are easy to lose, aren’t they, Marina Sofia? I’ve lost my share, too; and of course, my employer doesn’t reimburse without them. As you say, it’s much easier today with electronic documentation. Still, people do pay cash at times. There are other ways, too, to manipulate receipts if it’s important enough…

  2. A very interesting post, Margot with lots of great examples.

  3. Margot: In the most famous real life murder of my lifetime in Saskatchewan the accused, a former Cabinet Minister and son of a Premier, was alleged to have murdered or have murdered for him, his ex-wife in the garage of a house on the most heavily travelled street in Regina. Found outside the garage was a gas receipt for his vehicle. There was abundant argument on whether the receipt was lost by the accused, Colin Thatcher, or planted. Other evidence decided the case but the lowly receipt had its day in court.

    • Oh, that’s really interesting, Bill! I can certainly see how that receipt might make a big difference in the case, and I’m sure he probably didn’t even think about it when he first made the purchase. It’s fascinating how those little pieces of evidence – receipts and so on – can play such important roles in cases.

  4. I hate receipts. They seem to just be everywhere, cluttering. I’m forever clearing them out. It’s a good job I don’t plan on murdering anyone – well not in real life anyway 😉

    • I know what you mean, Rebecca. You should see my handbag sometimes! More paper than anything else in there, I sometimes think. And it always interests me how quickly a vital receipt (like a luggage ticket) becomes a useless waste of paper once it’s served its purpose. Yes, I think it’s best for both of us that we confine our murders to fiction… 😉

  5. I have spent the last 10 years of working life dealing with other peoples receipts (or missing ones) in film production accounting – it is amazing what you can learn from items on a receipt. 🙂

  6. My purse is full of receipts. This has reminded me to sort them out before I leave too much of a trail 😉

    • That’s probably just as well, D.S.. I do often wonder what assumptions people would make if they saw all of my receipts; probably best not to speculate too much… 😉

  7. Now that taxis give receipts that look official it makes travel easier for sure.

  8. Wow, I never realized how useful those receipts could be if a crime was committed and you needed to establish an alibi or that they could pinpoint a murderer. Fascinating!!

    • I thought so, too, Tracy, as I started planning this post. It’s so interesting just how important receipts can end up being, although it doesn’t seem that way.

  9. Pingback: Music Theme – Hidden | johnny ojanpera

  10. NOw you come to mention it, it’s surprising they’re not used more, isn’t it? And that’s quite some story from Bill in the comments above, not one I’d heard of before.

    • I think it’s surprising too, Moira. And about Bill’s story? I’m very glad he shared it; I hadn’t known about that story either, and it’s both fascinating and a terrific example of what I had in mind here. The fact that it really happened makes it all the more so.

  11. tracybham

    Vanish is the next book I want to read in the Rizzoli and Iles series. I have read the book by Colin Dexter and had forgotten that aspect of it. Need to try more of that series too.

  12. I always end up throwing my receipts away in bulk – so good to see one of my favourite of all the Morse stories featured on this post too.

    • I like The Silent World of Nicholas Quinn very much too, Cleo. I think it’s a very well-constructed mystery. And as to receipts? I do that too sometimes: let them collect and then get rid of them.

  13. Col

    Interesting post again Margot. I have the Gerritsen and Dexter books somewhere in the tubs!

  14. I watched that episode of Rizzoli and Iles but did not realize it was a novel… Vanish. How you come up with the ideas for these posts remains a mystery to me. Excellent!

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s