She Lived There With This Roommate I Despised*

RoommatesVery often, young people don’t have the means to purchase or even lease a place to live by themselves. So they room with another person (sometimes more than one person). In fact, rooming together is a lot more common at universities (especially for undergraduates) than is having a place to oneself.

The roommate relationship is a very unusual one, if you think about it. In a lot of cases, roommates are not relatives or family members. And yet, they may know more about one another than family does. And there are all kinds of things that can happen between roommates, too. If you’ve seen Barbet Schroeder’s Single White Female, you know some of what can happen. Even if you haven’t seen it, I’m sure you have your own ‘roommate stories.’

Roommates also figure into crime fiction. That makes sense, simply because of the relationship. Here are just a few examples.

Of course one of the best-known set of fictional roommates is Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson. For many of the stories in that series, they share rooms at perhaps crime fiction’s most famous address, 221B Baker Street. They’re very different people, but they manage to make it work.

Agatha Christie’s Third Girl is in part the story of three young women who share a London flat. Claudia Reese-Holland and Frances Cary share with Norma Restarick, who’s been brought in as a ‘third girl:’

‘The main girl takes a furnished flat, and then shares out the rent. Second girl is usually a friend. Then they find a third girl by advertising if they don’t know one…First girl takes the best room, second girl pays rather less, third girl less still and is stuck in a cat-hole.’

Norma pays a cryptic visit to Poirot, and then changes her mind, saying he’s ‘too old.’ Shortly thereafter, she disappears. Poirot’s friend, detective novelist Ariadne Oliver, knows who Norma is, and is interested in the mystery. So she works with Poirot to find out what happened to Norma and what it all may have to do with a murder that may have occurred. It’s an interesting look at taking a place together in London in the 1960s.

In Edward D. Hoch’s short story The Oblong Room, we meet university roommates Ralph Rollings and Tom McBern.  Connecticut police detective Captain Leopold is sent to the local university campus when Rollings’ body is found with stab wounds in it. McBern is in the room (which is locked), and apparently has been for two days. At first, no-one says anything about what happened – not McBern and not the young woman both roommates admired. Without any background, it’s hard to pinpoint a motive, but in the end, Leopold gets there. In this case, the motive is as unusual as the ‘locked room’ nature of this crime is.

Lawrence Block’s The Sins of the Fathers introduces readers to his sleuth Matthew Scudder. In this first novel, Scudder hasn’t yet got his PI license, but he does occasionally do a little very informal work for people. Successful businessman Cale Hanniford has heard about Scudder and want to hire him. Hanniford’s twenty-four-year-old daughter Wendy has been murdered, and all of the evidence points to her roommate, twenty-one-year-old Richard Vanderpoel. In fact, Hanniford doesn’t even want Scudder to investigate the murder. Rather, he wants to know more about the daughter from whom he’d become estranged. He’s hoping Scudder can help him understand the kind of person Wendy had become, and what led to her death. Rather reluctantly, Scudder agrees and asks some questions. As he does, he begins to wonder whether her roommate was actually responsible. In the end, he finds that Wendy’s murder is not as simple as it seems.

Neither is the murder of Kate Sumner, which we read about in Minette Walters’ The Breaker. Two young boys who out exploring find her body on the beach near Chapman’s Poole, Dorset. The alarm is raised and PC Nick Ingram begins to investigate. In the meantime, a toddler, who turns out to be Kate’s daughter Hannah, is found wandering around the nearby town of Poole. Gradually, the police trace the victim’s last days and weeks, and narrow the suspect list down to three people. One is Kate’s husband William. Another is a local schoolteacher Tony Bridges. A third is Bridges’ roommate, actor Stephen Harding. Without giving away spoilers, I can say that all three men had a motive, and that Kate’s complicated personal life and psychology have everything to do with her murder.

A group of college roommates features in Lisa Unger’s In the Blood. Lana Granger is a college senior who’s done everything possible to hide the darkness in her past. She’s managing, with difficulty at times, to function and is currently finishing her degree. As the story opens, she shares a dormitory suite with Rebecca ‘Beck’ Miller and a third roommate, Ainsley. Then, Lana’s mentor recommends her for an after-school nanny job supervising Luke Kahn. Luke’s had severe psychological/emotional problems; even on his best days, he can be difficult. Lana takes the job, although she’s a bit reluctant about it. Things begin to go downhill, as the saying goes, when Lana suspects that Luke is manipulating her. Then one terrible night, Beck disappears. It’s not long before she’s officially reported missing, and Lana becomes the chief suspect, since she had an argument with Beck that evening. Lana claims that she doesn’t know what happened to her roommate, but the police aren’t ready to take her word for it. And the more they learn about that night, the more they question what she says. The truth about what happened isn’t nearly as straightforward as it seems. Without spoiling the story, I can say that one of the things we see in this novel is college campus ‘roommate life.’

Living with someone who’s not a family member and not a romantic partner can be odd at times. In its way, it’s a very intimate relationship; yet, most of the time, roommates aren’t related. It’s certainly an interesting dynamic, so it’s no wonder it pops up in crime fiction. Got any ‘roommate war stories’ you’d like to share?


*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from The Mighty Mighty Bosstones’ She Just Happened.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Arthur Conan Doyle, Edward D. Hoch, Lawrence Block, Lisa Unger, Minette Walters

24 responses to “She Lived There With This Roommate I Despised*

  1. Of course, in the UK we call them flatmates or housemates rather than roommates, which would imply that you are actually sharing a room. I remember I was very confused when I first went to the US and visited a female friend who cheerfully introduced me to her male roommate… and I wasn’t sure if he was her significant other or not, what to say…

    • Those differences in terminology can be confusing, Marina Sofia. I once had a student (a second language learner of English) who’d learned UK English. In one of her classes (not one I was teaching), she was trying to use the back end of her pencil to correct an error on an in-class assignment. The back end broke off and fell on the floor and the young lady said, ‘Oh, no! I’ve lost my rubber!’ That certainly got the attention of her American English-speaking classmates, who say ‘eraser’ for the back end of a pencil, and ‘rubber’ for something quite different…

  2. Patti Abbott

    Sometimes when I have trouble getting to sleep I try to come up with a new theme for you. It is quite a challenge.

  3. Flatshares feature in the Ruth Rendell books Some Lie and Some Die & Murder Being Once Done. And under her other name, the Barbara Vine book Fatal Inversion has a group of young people sharing a house. I think it was a possibility the late lamented Ms Rendell liked exploring…

    • I think so too, Moira. Thanks for adding those examples in. She certainly had a talent for uncovering the kinds of things that might go on when people share digs.

  4. In one of the Rebus books – can’t remember which, but I bet you’ll know – Rebus has let out his flat to students, then breaks up with his girlfriend and moves back in. We see it from his perspective, living with a bunch of young people, but I must admit my pity was always for them – imagine having your grumply middle-aged policeman landlord move in on you! As we used to say in my student days, what a downer!!

    Laughed very hard at your ‘rubber’ story… 😆

    • Thought you’d appreciate that story, FictionFan. I felt badly for the student (very nice young lady), but she took it all in good stride. And as for the Rebus novel, are you thinking of The Falls? I think that’s the one where he and his girlfriend break up, but I could be wrong.

      • I wasn’t sure so I wiki’d and I think it’s “The Black Book”, where his brother Michael also moves in on the poor students. What fun!

        • Ah, yes! Right you are, Fiction Fan! Thank you. And yes, it’s great! Such a terrific dynamic of Rebus, Michael (with their own baggage) and the students. It really is fun 🙂

  5. Oh Margot – I had my share of housemates in my younger days and it is an experience! Love, as always, your examples – The Breaker by Minnette Walters and In The Blood in particular, both excellent crime novels.

    • I’m sure you could share some stories, Cleo! I think we all have them, to be honest. And thanks for the kind words 🙂 – Couldn’t agree more about the Walters – a fine novel.

  6. Col

    Loved this Scudder book from Lawrence Block!

  7. Plenty of room for conflict with roommates! Even *besides* murder. 🙂 Fun topic to explore as my son heads off to college this fall. I remember “The Breakers” but it’s been ages since I’ve read it. Might need to re-read.

    • Your son’s headed off to college, Elizabeth?! Wait! Wasn’t he just in middle school? Time goes too quickly. You’re right though about roommates: Lots of possibilities there for conflict and story lines!

  8. Since you asked… For a year I allowed a friend and her three year old child to stay with me. Big mistake. My friend never used the word “No” when it came to her daughter. And she was a nightmare, lining doorways with toothpaste, kicking my dog in the face, getting kicked out of every kindergarten she was enrolled in. It got so bad that I moved out of my own home, knowing she couldn’t afford it on her own. Which worked. After 25 years of friendship this ruined our relationship. We no longer speak.

  9. Kathy D.

    In crime fiction, there was a suspicious houseful of students in rural Ireland in Tana French’s The Likeness and a murder to solve. Then in The Secret Place there were boarding school roommates and the detectives have to solve a year-old murder and figure out which young woman did it.
    As far as personal roommate stories go, well, there were college roommates and first few apartment roommates. Some of it was fine.
    But college years were during the 60s and I went to a liberal school so there was a lot of imbibing bad substances around, a roommate who’d keep me up all night keeping me laughing. One issue that is rarely brought up in articles about problems on campuses is “heartbreak.” Between roommates being depressed over break-ups, some of which were doozies, and finding guys who’d been dumped by my roommate sitting in my room upset when I woke up, there was a lot of this going around. So romance-induced depression was all around. It’s a wonder anyone got work done.
    Then living in Boston with several women, I found out later a partner of one of them was tormenting my cat and engaging in illegal activities.
    Then in an apartment in my now-city an apartment mate’s dog chased my cat, causing a stereo speaker to fall on his tail. That poor cat had a half a tail.

    • Thanks, Kathy for mentioning The Likeness. It’s a terrific example of the kind of interrelationships that can develop among housemates. They can get really complicated.
      And you’re quite right about the impact of heartbreak. It’s often a huge factor in relationships among roommates. And of course, the topic makes for all sorts of conversation and drama. It can make for conflict, too.
      I’m sorry to hear about what happened to your cat, too. I didn’t think about pet issues (believe it or not!) when I was planning this post. No doubt, though, pets can add another layer to a roommate relationship. And of course, it’s one of many things that can come up.

  10. I loved Patti’s comment. I am going to have to try that.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s