Is There Life After Breakfast?*

BreakfastIt’s been said that breakfast is the most important meal of the day. And it’s not hard to see why people have that view. After all, breakfast gets you going in the morning. Breakfast is also a really useful meal for fiction writers.

For one thing, breakfast is a very culturally contextual meal (they all are, really). In some cultures, and contexts, a heavier breakfast is the custom. In others, one eats a light breakfast, and then a heavier lunch or dinner. What’s more, the foods that one eats for breakfast vary by culture.

Breakfast is also a very individual sort of habit. Each of us is a bit different with respect to what and how much we eat in the morning. For the writer, this means that breakfast can be a very effective way to show what a character is like, both culturally and as an individual.

Breakfast can be the setting for effective scenes, too. Those scenes can add to the tension of a story, or to the portraits of the characters. So it’s little wonder that breakfast is woven into a lot of crime fiction.

Fans of Agatha Christie will know that her Hercule Poirot is a chocolate-and-croissant sort of breakfast eater. He’s not much of a one for the traditional, larger ‘Englishman’s breakfast.’ Just that simple fact about him shows readers something of his cultural background.

Christie uses breakfast scenes quite frequently to build story contexts, too. For example, the first chapter of The Murder of Roger Ackroyd is titled, Dr. Sheppard at the Breakfast Table. In it, Dr. James Sheppard, who is the local GP for the village of King’s Abbot, comes home after a very early call. His sister Caroline, who keeps house for him, joins him for a traditional eggs-and-bacon breakfast. At that time, and in that place, breakfast wasn’t a matter of grabbing a protein bar. As the two are talking, we learn about the death of one of the village’s residents, Mrs. Ferrars. That conversation sets the stage for what’s to come next in the novel – the stabbing death of retired business magnate Roger Ackroyd. There are other Christie novels, too (Dead Man’s Folly comes to my mind) in which a breakfast scene gives readers both context and character development.

Some authors use breakfast places and scenes to build a sense of local culture. That’s what Craig Johnson does in his Walt Longmire series. Longmire lives in the small town of Durant, Wyoming. He lives alone and doesn’t do a lot of cooking for himself. But he doesn’t need to, because Durant is home to the Busy Bee Café, owned and operated by Dorothy Caldwell. The Bee, as it’s called, is where the locals go for pancakes, eggs, and other ‘homestyle’ cooking. And coffee. That sort of breakfast food reflects both the small-town context for this series, and the local culture.

Breakfast choices are also very much reflections of the individual. For instance, in D.S. Nelson’s Blake Heatherington stories, we learn that Heatherington’s breakfast preference is an almond croissant. That fits well with his lifestyle (he’s not really the ‘outdoors, strenuous exercise’ type) and his age (he’s – erm – no longer twenty). On the other hand, his detective partner Delilah Delibes, who is much younger and more energetic, prefers a fried breakfast. Not only do their breakfast conversations give readers background for the mysteries, but they also show readers a bit of what these two people are like.

There’s also Reginald Hill’s Superintendent Andy Dalziel. As fans will know, he’s a born-and-bred Yorkshireman who enjoys his food. His personality is reflected in his breakfast choices, too. In Recalled to Life, for instance, Dalziel has gone to the US to follow up on a long-ago murder case that’s stirred up a lot of interest. In this scene, American journalist Linda Steele invites him to breakfast:

‘‘I’ll not quarrel with that. Can I get bacon and eggs? I don’t suppose they do black pudding.’
‘Never mind. I like me bacon crisp enough to shave with, and me eggs like a parrot’s eye.’
Linda Steele translated the order into American and the waitress replied in kind.
‘She wants to know if you want syrup.’
‘No, thanks. Marmalade.’
‘With your eggs?’
‘With my toast! Bloody hell, you’ll be offering me kippers and custard next.’’

This bit not only shows Dalziel’s personality, but it also shows gives an interesting cultural perspective.

People’s breakfast choices often become a part of their daily life, too, so that it’s very hard to change them. For example, in Martin Edwards’ The Cipher Garden, we learn that a big change is coming to the Cumbria Constabulary:

‘The senior management team had insisted that the catering franchisee should wipe the Big All Day Breakfast off the menu during summer.’

The idea is that officers should develop healthier eating habits. But that change is certainly not universally accepted. The series features DCI Hannah Scarlett, head of the constabulary’s Cold Case Review Team. In this novel, her second-in-command is Nick Lowther, who

‘…still preferred calorie-laden junk food that resembled an exhibit in a long-ago poisoning.’

Scarlett’s friend and fellow DCI Fern Larter isn’t much of a fan of the new healthy eating initiative either. In The Serpent Pool, she and Scarlett agree to meet for breakfast at the Beast Banks Breakfast Bar. Larter chooses

‘…eggs, bacon, sausage, baked beans, fried bread and black pudding.’

She’s not one to be dictated to by policies.

Breakfast choices can be influenced by generation, too. For example, Anthony Bidulka’s Saskatoon PI Russell Quant doesn’t eat a big breakfast as a rule. But his mother Kay sees things differently. She is a farm wife, who’s spent her adult life cooking heavy-duty farm breakfasts with a Ukrainian flair. So when she comes to stay with her son in Flight of Aquavit, there’s an interesting generation clash about what ‘counts’ as breakfast.

There are a lot of other examples, too, of the way that breakfast choices show us what characters and local cultures are like. Some people simply eat cereal (I see you, Jill Edmondson’s Sasha Jackson). Others don’t eat breakfast at all. Still others (you see this in a lot of classic/Golden Age novels) have breakfast served in bed. Sometimes small details like that add depth to characters and contexts to stories in ways that a lot of words wouldn’t. And let’s face it: breakfast resonates with most of us.


*NOTE: The title of this post is the title of a Ray Davies song.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Anthony Bidulka, Craig Johnson, D.S. Nelson, Jill Edmondson, Martin Edwards, Reginald Hill

20 responses to “Is There Life After Breakfast?*

  1. It will come as no surprise that Nero Wolfe, to whom the enjoyment of food was one of the primary goals in life, was as particular about breakfast as he was about other meals. In Over My Dead Body, we see Wolfe breakfasting in bed (of course!) on”orange juice, eggs au beurre noir, two slices of broiled Georgia ham, hashed brown potatoes, hot blueberry muffins, and a pot of steaming cocoa.

    It is also worth noting that in The Mother Hunt, Wolfe explains that it takes at least forty minutes to make scrambled eggs, “every particle exquisitely firm, soft, and moist.” The recipe may be found in The Nero Wolfe Cookbook.

    • Oh, I was hoping you’d mention Wolfe, Les. Trust you to give perfect examples of exactly the sort of delicious breakfast detail I had in mind with this post. You filled in the gap beautifully, for which thanks.

  2. Sadly, breakfast is the one thing that Italian detectives do not seem to enjoy as much as their other meals: Montalbano, Zen, Brunetti all make do with that cup of espresso and at most a biscuit. Very sad!

  3. Very interesting, Margot. I don’t remember breakfast scenes in crime fiction but I often read about sleuths and investigators drinking coffee most of the time. I think Poirot loves his tea though I don’t recall him sitting down to a nice breakfast.

    • That’s quite true, Prashant; lots and lots of fictional detectives are coffee addicts. Sometimes I think it’s a job requirement. 😉 – As to Poirot, I don’t recall his having a big breakfast either. He enjoys his croissant, and sometimes an egg (if it’s cooked exactly right). But you’re right that he doesn’t typically eat heavily at breakfast.

  4. I loved that Les mentioned Nero Wolfe’s scrambled eggs. I tried that recipe when I was in my twenties. I actually learned to make eggs that way earlier in a high school class. It is a lot of work but Wolfe likes his eggs just the way I do.

    Breakfast is my favorite meal for eating out. We do eat out every Saturday morning and when we have some vacation days.

    In the Sue Grafton novel I read recently, there were some great food scenes and some were related to breakfast, although I cannot recall details. Kinsey’s thoughts on these kinds of things reveal a lot of her character.

    • Oh, you’re absolutely right, Tracy. You can see the kind of personality that Kinsey Millhone has just from her way of thinking about eating. And that includes breakfast. Your comments about eating breakfast out remind me of a popular restaurant near where I live. On weekend mornings, there are always long lines to get in. I’ve been there myself a couple of times, and I can see why. There’s just something about breakfast food, I suppose. And it’s good to know (‘though not surprising) that Nero Wolfe’s egg recipe is tasty.

  5. Col

    The last few books I’ve read it’s mainly just been coffee to go for our characters. Much like myself!

  6. You come up with the coolest examples, Margot. I love “The Bee” in Longmire. So many good scenes happened there, at least in the TV series.

  7. I’ve given up being surprised by the topics you can use for a blogpost Margot! This is a great one. I’m thinking Lord Peter Wimsey likes his breakfast and it features in several of the books.

    • Thank you, Moira. And thanks for the example of Lord Peter Wimsey. He is a great character, and yes, breakfast figures into several scenes in those novels; glad you filled in that gap.

  8. Just catching up with your posts. I love writing about Blake and Delilah’s eating habits. Thanks for mentioning them. Food features heavily in my novels, I fear it says something about my out psyche. Of course, I’m not worried about what the murders say about me 😉

    • I don’t like to think about that, either, D.S. 😉 – Writing crime fiction certainly does say something about one, and I’m not sure I always like it… But about food? Now that is a topic that’s easy to enjoy. And it really does reveal a lot about characters when we know those things like what they like to eat for breakfast, or whether they’re coffee or tea people. Touches of that add character depth, I think.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s