Hide it in a Hiding Place Where No One Ever Goes*

Ingenious Hiding PlacesWhere would crime fiction be without the ingenious hiding place? All sorts of valuable things are hidden throughout the genre: wills, letters, jewels, even a horse (more on that shortly). And a garden-variety hiding place (in a drawer or behind a picture) isn’t nearly as interesting as something more ingenious. Of course, an ingenious hiding place still has to be believable, or crime fiction fans won’t ‘buy’ it. Even with that, though, there’s plenty of leeway for some interesting hiding places, and lots of authors have made use of thtem. Here are a few examples.

In Arthur Conan Doyle’s Silver Blaze, Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson travel to Dartmoor to investigate the disappearance of a famous racehorse Silver Blaze (See? Here’s the one about the horse), and the murder of the horse’s trainer, John Straker. Inspector Tobias Gregory has arrested London bookmaker Fitzroy Simpson, and he did have motive, since he has a lot at stake in an upcoming race that Silver Blaze is scheduled to run. But there are pieces of evidence that suggest that Simpson is not the killer. And for all his imperfections as a detective (at least, that’s how Holmes sees it), he doesn’t want an innocent man convicted. So he’s asked Holmes to look into the matter. Silver Blaze is, of course, missing. So along with solving Straker’s murder, Holmes and Watson have to also find out where Silver Blaze is hidden. It’s really quite an ingenious place, actually. I know, I know, fans of The Adventure of the Six Napoleons.

Agatha Christie used clever hiding places in several of her stories. For example, in Death on the Nile, Hercule Poirot and Colonel Race investigate the murder of Linnet Ridgeway Doyle, who was shot on the second night of a honeymoon cruise of the Nile. The most likely suspect is her former best friend Jacqueline ‘Jackie’ de Bellefort, but it’s soon proven that she could not have committed the murder. So Poirot and Race have to re-think their ideas. In the meantime, it’s been noticed that some valuable pearls belonging to the victim have disappeared. Besides their intrinsic value, their theft could possibly have been a motive for murder. So a search is undertaken for them. It turns out that they’ve been hidden in a very interesting place. I know, I know, fans of The Man in the Brown Suit, and The Case of the Missing Will.

Ellery Queen’s short story The Adventure of the One-Penny Black presents another really interesting hiding place. In that story, Queen and Sergeant Velie investigate the disappearance of a very rare stamp called a one-penny black – one of a valuable pair. It’s gone missing from the collection of avid philatelists Friedrich and Albert Ulm, who are particularly anxious about it, because it’s got Queen Victoria’s signature on it. Of course, there are dozens of places where one might hide a stamp. But Queen makes some deductions and, after being pulled off the trail briefly, finds out what happened to that stamp. It turns out to have been a very clever hiding place.

Donna Leon’s Blood From a Stone begins with the execution-style shooting of an unidentified Senegalese immigrant. One day, he’s laying out his wares in one of Venice’s open-air markets when he is murdered. It all happens so fast that no-one really sees the killer or the actual incident. What’s worse, no-one knows the victim. To most people he’s ‘just another immigrant,’ with no real identity. And he doesn’t have any identification. That’s going to make it difficult to find out who he was and who wanted to kill him. Still, Brunetti and Ispettore Lorenzo Vianello persist; eventually they trace the man to the house that he shared with several other immigrants. That presents another challenge. For obvious reasons, the other people with whom the victim lived do not trust the police. What’s more, there’s a language barrier. Still, Brunetti and Vianello manage to learn a few things about the man, and they find out which room in the house he was using. As they search through his things, they discover a box of salt. Buried inside the salt is a cache of diamonds. Now the case takes on a whole new meaning. As it turns out, the victim’s death is connected to arms trafficking and to ‘conflict diamonds.’

And then there’s Steve Robinson’s In the Blood. Wealthy Boston businessman Walter Sloane hires genealogist Jefferson Tayte for a special family search. He wants Tayte to trace his wife’s ancestry as a gift to her, and Tayte takes the commission. He traces the family all the way back to her first American-born ancestor William Fairborne. That line died out; however, another branch of the family continued. In 1783, so Tayte learns, Fairborne’s brother James took his family to England with a group of Loyalists. Sloan wants Tayte to pursue this line, so Tayte makes the trip to Cornwall, where the modern-day Fairbornes live. Almost immediately he faces several challenges. One is that there are no records of Fairborne’s wife and children after his arrival. There’s only a record of another marriage two years later. So what happened to the Fairbornes?  Another is that the modern Fairborne family is not interested in helping him. They have a lot of social status and local ‘clout,’ too, so very few other people are willing to give Tayte any information. One day, by chance, he meets Amy Fallon, who is working on a mystery of her own. Two years earlier, her husband Gabriel died at sea in a storm. Before he died, he told Amy that he’d found out a secret, but never got the chance to tell her what he’d discovered. Since then, though, construction on their home, Ferryman Cottage, has revealed a hidden staircase that leads to a secret room beneath the house. In that room, Fallon has discovered an antique writing box. That writing box turns out to contain an important clue to Tayte’s mystery.

There are, of course, dozens of other mysteries that feature ingenious and unusual hiding places for papers, wills, jewels, and a lot of other things too. Which ones do you like best?



*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Simon and Garfunkel’s Mrs. Robinson.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Arthur Conan Doyle, Donna Leon, Ellery Queen, Steve Robinson

29 responses to “Hide it in a Hiding Place Where No One Ever Goes*

  1. Each time you mention In The Blood I think, ooh, I’ve got to read that. I love secret hiding places in crime fiction.

    • I do, too, Sue. And I do recommend In the Blood. Jefferson Tayte is a human, approachable sort of character. Speaking just for me, I found it easy to cheer for him.

  2. Kathy D.

    Of course, any book by Donna Leon featuring Guido Brunetti is a good one, in my book. Am now reading the 24th Brunetti novel which features the terrified opera singer, Flavia Petrelli, focus of the first book, Death at Le Fenice and a later one, Acqua Alta.
    This one has a few unique moments: an exchange between Paola Falier and her spouse, Brunetti, about Petrarch, and Elettra Zorzi going on strike at the Questura and reading a book by famous mystery writer Sciascia at her desk. The title is Falling in Love. All Brunetti fans should get it.
    Amazing this series has lasted for 24 books. I read it as nectar from the gods, savoring every page.

    • I’m so glad you’re enjoying the book, Kathy. It certainly says something about a series when it lasts through 24 books, all of which are popular and well-regarded. And it’s interesting how Leon brings in earlier characters in this one.

  3. Col

    I just listened to a long short story where a thief was using the store owner’s hollowed out walking stick – a present he had given him – to steal maps from his bookshop.

    I like the old school espionage book where information would be secreted and had to be smuggled past a border and out of a country, though naturally examples escape me!

    • I know what you mean, Col. There are some great old stories where maps, papers and so on are taken across borders in all kinds of different ways. They’re so creative! And that story you listened to sounds good, too!

  4. I now want to know where the horse was hidden!

  5. Some great hiding places there Margot. I working on the plot for the next book, which involves hiding places in plain sight. Always the best ones, in my humble opinion 🙂

  6. Margot, there was a time when the old trunk in the attic or the locker at the bus station held many secrets including the key that’d help unmask the culpri(s) and solve the crime. In fact, I’m currently reading an ebook where two US marines are framed over a secret programme in Iraq and their only hope lies in the contents of a mysterious locked at the station.

    • Oh, yes of course, Prashant! The locked trunk or locker offers so many possibilities for tension, plot points, and so on. I’m glad you mentioned that. I hope you’ll post a review of the book you’re reading; I’d be keen to know what it’s like.

  7. Agatha Christie again: in The Hollow, one of her best, there are 2 clever hiding places, for the gun and separately for the holster…

  8. Another relevant post of In The Blood, a book I love and that hiding place was an ingenious one.

  9. One of the key problems to be solved by Judge Dee in Robert Van Gulik’s Necklace and Calabash is the disappearance of a very valuable pearl necklace, stolen from the emperor’s daughter. Even when the thief has been identified, the necklace cannot be found – which would be disastrous for the princess. As Judge Dee will discover, the way it has been hidden is truly ingenious.

    • Oh, that’s a fabulous example, Les! Thank you! And that’s not the only ingenious hiding place we see in the Dee series. In my humble opinion, Van Gulik was good at thinking of such places…

  10. Margot, you keep reminding me of authors I need to read. This time it is Steve Robinson.

  11. One of my favorite bizarre hiding places is in the Nero Wolfe mystery Help Wanted, Male. Wolfe hires a body double until he can flush out the stalker intent on killing him.

    Where the stalker is hiding is the best hiding place I’ve seen in a mystery yet. Pretty sure it fooled me in the PBS series and again when I read the book years later.

  12. philipcoggan

    Col’s mention of the hollowed-out walking stick reminded me of something: walking stick as gun. Actually, a shooting-stick – they were reasonably common once, and are indistinguishable from a simple walking stick, especially if a 19th century antique were used today as a murder weapon. The weapon can be hidden in plain sight.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s