In The Spotlight: Marek Krajewski’s Death in Breslau

SpotlightHello, All,

Welcome to another edition of In The Spotlight. ‘Hardboiled’ crime fiction often features moral ambiguity; and the sleuths in them frequently do things that we might find reprehensible. But they have to operate within a sometimes violent and dysfunctional context, where the rules are different. So it’s not always easy to say what the ‘right’ thing is to do. As an example of this sort of novel, let’s turn today’s spotlight on Marek Krajewski’s Death in Breslau, the first of his Eberhard Mock novels.

It’s 1934, and Mock is a Breslau (Wroclaw) detective and Criminal Counsellor to the police department. His involvement in this story begins when his assistant Max Forstner tracks him down to a brothel to let him know that Baron Olivier van der Malten’s seventeen-year-old daughter Marietta, and her governess, Françoise Debroux, have been raped and murdered, with scorpions found in Marietta’s remains. There’s also a cryptic inscription near the bodies. Mock owes his career to the protection of the baron and his Masonic Lodge brothers, so he’s not in a position to refuse when van der Malten summons him to take personal charge of the case.

The official police explanation, and one that’s sanctioned by the Gestapo, is that a Jewish man by the name of Isidor Friedlander is responsible for the crimes. But the Baron is sure that’s not the case. Since Mock is beholden to him, he agrees when the Baron insists that he work with Criminal Assistant Herbert Anwaldt to find out the truth about these murders. So Mock and Anwaldt begin looking into the case.

One of the leads they explore is the cryptic inscription that was left with the bodies. For information on this, they work with Dr. Georg Maass, an expert on Oriental languages and the occult. With his expertise, they learn of a horrible 13th Century crime committed by a Crusader and a Turk against the children of a Yazidi. That crime turns out to have repercussions in the modern era, and as Mock and Andwaldt work the crime, they also have to dig through history to find out the truth behind the murders.

Much of the action in the novel takes place during the early and mid-1930’s, as the Gestapo come to power. At the time, the city is called Breslau and is part of Germany, so Mock and his team have every reason to be concerned about Nazi interest in what they’re doing. This is particularly true given the Nazi dislike of Masonry, and given the local Nazi authorities’ satisfaction with their case against Friedlander. In fact, in one small sub-plot of this story, Mock becomes aware that there’s a Gestapo informant among his staff.

Breslau/Wroclaw is a border city in the area between Germany and Poland, so there’s a strong Polish influence in the area, too. Krajewski depicts life in this multicultural landscape as Mock and Anwaldt go back and forth between the two countries and talk to people of several different backgrounds.

This is a noir story, so several of the characters aren’t what they seem on the surface. Mock knows that he can’t really be sure exactly whom to trust. And almost all of the characters, including Mock, have their ways of being manipulative and deceptive. No-one’s hands are really clean, so to speak, in this story. Because this is a hardboiled novel, there is also great deal of violence, some of it brutal. Readers who dislike a lot of violence in their novels will notice that. In that way, this isn’t an easy novel to read.

Mock has been shaped by this culture and has to survive within it. He has some university background in classics and philosophy, but is a very pragmatic person, even when it mans doing things we might find reprehensible. He’s somewhat fatalistic, and certainly isn’t cheerful or optimistic about much. That said, though, he has no patience with the Gestapo’s bullying ways or with some of the deception he uncovers. In this case, he’s on ‘the side of the angels’ as he works to find out the truth.

Mock’s relationship with Anwaldt is another element in this novel. He starts out by not caring much for Anwaldt, and it’s not hard to see why. Andwaldt has been drinking too much (although he does try to sober up for this case), and Mock isn’t inclined to find most people likeable anyway. But as the novel goes on, he develops a bond of sympathy with Andwaldt, and finds ways to take care of him. For his part, Anwaldt knows how much he owes Mock; and in his way, he is loyal.

The story is told in a very roughly chronological way, except for the beginning chapter. There is some movement back and forth through time as we learn about the personal histories of some of the characters, and as we learn about the 13th-Century incident that seems to be at the core of this case. However, each chapter is clearly marked with the place and time, so readers can easily follow the story line. Still, those who prefer a strictly linear novel will notice this pattern.

As you would expect, given the sort of story this is, the solution isn’t a happy one. Finding out the truth not only doesn’t make things all right again, it makes things even more difficult for some characters. This isn’t light reading, and the end of the novel is in keeping with that. Still, readers do learn what happened and why, and without spoiling the story, I can say that some characters ‘get theirs.’

Death in Breslau is a hardboiled story of murder in the distinctive Polish/German area around Wroclaw/Breslau during the early years of the Nazi regime. It features a pragmatic sleuth who does his best to function in a very chaotic world. It also features a past/present connection that has a real impact. But what’s your view? Have you read Death in Breslau? If you have, what elements do you see in it?


Coming Up On In The Spotlight


Monday 7 December/Tuesday 8 December – Blue Monday – Nicci French

Monday 14 December/Tuesday 15 December – White Heat – M.J. McGrath

Monday 21 December/Tuesday 22 December – A Madras Miasma – Brian Stoddart


Filed under Death in Breslau, Marek Krajewski, Uncategorized

24 responses to “In The Spotlight: Marek Krajewski’s Death in Breslau

  1. Excellent post, Margot. I have to confess I struggled a little with the more (ahem) gruesome elements of this novel’s crime scene and need to reread the novel and to explore the others in the Mock series further. The historical and political contexts are fascinating and the figure of the compromised detective is a highly intriguing one.

    • Thank you very much, Mrs. P. To be honest, I struggled with the violence, too. You’re quite right about the contexts, and I think Krajewski handles them very effectively. And Mock is definitely a complicated, compromised detective.

  2. Col

    It’s been a few years since I read the first two in this series and I really didn’t like these books at all, which is possibly surprising because I do prefer the darker elements or extremes of the genre in the main. I didn’t find them particularly easy reads, they don’t exactly flow and I didn’t care for the main character or buy into the 13th C connection. After that there wasn’t too much left for me to enjoy!

    • No book/series is for everyone Col, even if it’s in a category that one usually enjoys. And if you don’t care for the main character, don’t like the flow, and don’t buy part of the story, then it isn’t just a case of one or two annoying things.

  3. As someone going to Poland and Germany in May, this sounds fabulous.

    • I didn’t know you were going to Germany and Poland, Patti – that’s exciting!! This novel really does evoke the place, at least as it was at the time the novel takes place.

  4. Great spotlight as always, Margot, but I’m delighted to say I don’t think this one will make its way on to my TBR. The setting sounds interesting, and I’m intrigued by the 13th century connection. But I’ve had my fill of gruesome violence – for a while, at least.

    • Thanks, FictionFan. The setting, both physical and historical, are, I think, done very effectively. But the book does have its share of brutal violence. It’s not a book for those who are looking for an easier read in that sense. And now at least you can’t say I always add to your TBR. 😉

  5. I must read this book, Margot!. It has been sitting for a long time on my TBR shelves.

    • I have books like that, too, José Ignacio – books that have been waiting too long for me to read. If you do get to this one, I’ll be keen to know what you think of it.

  6. Thanks Margot – I have ordered this as it sounds very interesting to me -( so have only read parts of your spotlight, as a result, though I know you are a spoiler-free lady). Thanks 🙂

  7. Thanks for the thorough review and introduction. I haven’t read this and before your post, I’d never heard of the Mock series. I’m so glad I found your article today. I actually like reading some of the darker and even gruesome books in this genre. I’m particularly fascinated with historical mysteries that are set during that time frame and the setting is one I am sure to devour. My father’s side of the family ( Jewish) is from Poland and I’ve heard stories my entire life of the old country. I hope I can visit Poland and Germany before I die. It wasn’t part of my trip to Europe when I was young and I’ve regretted that decision ever since.

    I’m looking forward to reading this book and hopefully more in the series. Monk promises to be a complicated, complex detective whose moral compass appears aimed in the right direction. My take on him, without having read any of the books, yet, it that the end result always justifies the means. I guess I’ll have to read and find out for myself. I’m very grateful for a new author and new series to begin reading. Thank you.

    Melissa Sugar

    • It’s interesting that you have a family connection to Poland, Melissa. I think this novel gives the reader a real sense of the Poland/Germany border area during the early/mid-1930s. And Mock really is a complicated person who has to function in a dangerous place during a very complicated time. I’ll be interested in what you think of this book/series if you do get the chance to read it.

  8. I’m more of a contemporary type of gal, but you’ve made this book so intriguing. Definitely piqued my interest enough to read the sample as see where it goes. Thanks, Margot.

    • It’s a complex book, Sue, and in some places not at all easy to read. But there’s a lot to it, and lots to think about as you read. If you do give it a try, I’ll be interested in your reaction.

  9. Nicely reviewed, Margot. I’m definitely tempted to read this particular novel in the Mock series. I find the interconnected elements of history, Gestapo, and violence quite appealing in the backdrop of the crime.

    • Thank you, Prashant. I think the historical aspects of this novel, and the sociological aspects, are quite effectively done. I’ll be interested in your thoughts on this book if you read it.

  10. Nice spotlight Margot, but I’d have to be in the right mood for a book like that, and I’m not at the moment.

  11. As enticing as your review of this book is, Margot, I think I shall pass–at least for the foreseeable future. Perhaps, as I just now noticed you’ve suggested above to Moira, when I’m ready.

    • It’s definitely a book you need to be prepared to read, Matt. It’s a very uncomfortable read in some places. It’s a solid picture of the era, and with some great characters, but not an easy book.

  12. This book does sound like it covers a difficult subject, but I am planning on giving it a try. My husband read the first one and he liked it, with some reservations. He did pass the book on to me, so I hope to get to it sometime soon (relatively speaking).

    • I know what you mean about getting to things when you can, Tracy. There’s never enough time to read everything one wants to read, I’ve found. This one is, admittedly, difficult to read because of the subject matter. But it’s well-written, I think.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s