Will You Give All You Can Give*

risking-to-helpWe’ve all read and heard stories of those who risked everything, including their lives, to right a wrong and/or to help others. While some of them are well-known, others are not so well-known. For instance, do you know who Miep Gies was? She was a secretary for the Dutch offices of the German firm, Opekta. She was also one of those who helped to hide Otto Frank (who worked for Opekta), his wife, Edith, and their daughters, Margot and Anne, among others, from the Nazis. Miep and her husband Jan (who was a member of the Dutch Resistance) took grave risks to help the Frank family and the others who hid with them. What makes this story especially remarkable is that neither Gies was what you call a ‘superhero.’ They were ordinary people who did extraordinary things.

They aren’t the only examples of such courage, of course. We’ve seen them in real life, and we see them in crime fiction, too. It’s a bit tricky to create such a character, because it’s so important that the character be believable. But when they’re well-drawn, characters who risk everything to help others, or to do good, can add much to a story. They can be interesting in and of themselves, and the risks they take can add tension to a plot.

In Agatha Christie’s short story, The Theft of the Royal Ruby (AKA The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding), Hercule Poirot is persuaded against his better judgement, to spend Christmas at Kings Lacey, the home of Colonel Horace Lacey, his wife, Em, their grandchildren and great-niece, and some other house guests. Poirot is ostensibly there to experience an old-fashioned English Christmas. But the real reason for his visit is to recover a valuable ruby that was stolen from an Eastern prince. On Christmas Eve, Poirot finds a note on his pillow, warning him not to eat any of the Christmas pudding. He’s puzzled, but doesn’t ignore the note. The pudding becomes important in the recovery of the jewel, and Poirot discovers that the author of the note is the family maid, Annie. It’s not spoiling the story to say that she didn’t steal the ruby. But she does take quite a risk, especially considering her position, in warning Poirot of what she sees as real danger to him.

Rebecca Cantrell’s Hannah Vogel series takes place mostly in Berlin, just before and during the Nazi era. As the series begins (with A Trace of Smoke), Vogel is a crime reporter for the Berliner Tageblatt. The Nazis are rising to power, and it’s getting more and more dangerous to oppose them. This makes it challenging enough for Vogel (and for many other Germans). But she’s got another challenge. She and her brother Ernst lent their identity papers to two Jewish friends who needed them to escape Berlin. Those friends have promised to return the papers, but the Vogels took a real risk. When Vogel discovers that her brother has been murdered, she has to be extremely cautious in finding out why and by whom. If she’s caught without papers, her doom is sealed. As the series goes on, she takes other risks, too. Fans of the novels will know that, more than once, she goes up against the Nazis as she finds out the truth of what they’ve been doing.

Ernesto Mallo’s Needle in a Haystack introduces Buenos Aires police detective Venancio ‘Perro’ Lescano. He lives and works in the late 1970s, a very dangerous time for most people in Buenos Aires. With the military government firmly in control, any whisper of dissent is brutally put down, and anyone who is considered to have ‘the wrong’ sympathies simply disappears. Against that backdrop, Lescano is called one morning to a riverbank where three bodies have been dumped. Two of them look like regular ‘army hits,’ and Lescano knows better than to question them if he can possibly avoid it. The third, though, is a little different. It turns out that this is the body of a moneylender named Elías Biterman, and Lescano doesn’t think he was killed in the usual way. So, very quietly, he begins an investigation. The trail leads to the very highest levels, and Lescano himself takes risks as he looks into the matter. He’s not the only one. When a court office boy named Marcelo discovers some very incriminating documents, he risks his life to get them to Lescano, and they play an important role in the case. Lescano is also helped by the medical examiner, Dr. Fusili, who risks his life to get to the real cause of Biterman’s death.

Malla Nunn’s DS Emmanuel Cooper has to take real risks, as well. This series takes place in the early 1950s, not long after South Africa’s apartheid laws were enacted. In the first novel, A Beautiful Place to Die, Cooper (who is white) is sent from Johannesburg to the small town of Jacob’s Rest to investigate the murder of Willem Pretorius. During the course of this investigation, we see the way the apartheid laws impact every aspect of life. Breaking any of them causes trouble; opposing them can be a fatal decision. Cooper, though, is determined to find out who killed the victim and why. In the course of doing so, he finds himself up against some very dangerous odds. And anyone who helps him faces risks, too. As the series goes on, we see that Cooper risks his life more than once to do the right thing.

So do several characters in David Whish-Wilson’s Line of Sight. This novel, which takes place in late-1970s Perth, features Superintendent Frank Swann. Swann left Perth several years earlier, but returns when he learns that a friend, Ruby Devine, has been murdered. He’s taking a risk looking into the case, as he’s already a ‘marked man.’  That’s because he convened a Royal Commission investigation into the activities of a group of corrupt police known as the ‘purple circle.’ They’ve got plenty of power, and aren’t afraid to use it, as brutally as necessary. Going against them can amount to a death sentence, so not many people are willing to help Swann. But a few brave people are. And in the end, we learn what happened to Ruby.

It takes a great deal of courage to risk everything in order to help others, or to right a wrong. But those who do make all the difference in the world. And they can serve as interesting characters in a crime novel.


*NOTE: The title of this post is a line from Michel Schönberg and Herbert Kretzmer’s Do You Hear the People Sing?


Filed under Agatha Christie, David Whish-Wilson, Ernesto Mallo, Malla Nunn, Rebecca Cantrell

28 responses to “Will You Give All You Can Give*

  1. A somewhat timely post about courage.
    Nicely pulled together

  2. Tim

    It seems to me that your premise pertains to all policemen: they protect and serve. Hence, crime novels are filled to overflowing with people giving all they can give. But perhaps I am being too simple and superficial.

    • You certainly have a point, Tim, that police officers risk their lives. I don’t think that’s too superficial. I wonder And those who protect all citizens, despite messages to do otherwise, have even more courage.

  3. Tim

    Correction: police officers (i.e., inclusive noun) v. policemen (i.e., gender specific and exclusive noun)

  4. A great post about those brave fictional characters who are believable because we do hear such stories in ‘real’ life too. Love your examples Margot.

  5. Great post, Margot. I love a credible, courageous character. I think Sulari Gentill’s Rowland Sinclair is another who puts himself in harm’s way for the sake of others and his principles.

  6. I believe Matt Beynon Rees’ character, Omar Yussef also fits the category. A Palestinian and a teacher, he gets involved in mysteries, often conflicting with the Israelis and his own people, but never falters in his courage.

  7. A great topic in these troubled times, Margot! I’ll add CJ Sansom’s Matthew Shardlake, if I may. He’s always reluctant to get dragged into the murky politics of the day, but it’s precisely because he has built a reputation for doing the right thing regardless of the personal cost to him and his friends that makes the rich and powerful turn to him for help.

    • Thanks for the kind words, FictionFan. And I couldn’t agree more about Matthew Shardlake. He has enough courage to go against the highest authorities if that’s where the truth lies. And I think you’re right; that also means people trust him. Certainly they trust him more than they would a toady. It’s one thing I like about his character.

  8. Keishon

    Yes, to echo others, thanks for highlighting courageous characters who risk everything to do the right thing in fiction novels. I enjoy such stories and find them very emotional, gripping and inspiring. You mentioned Malla Nunn who I adore (and a little behind) and Ernesto Mallo, I guess we won’t be getting that third book in the series that I occasionally look for. Those are examples of crime fiction that I love. Real life adversities with fictional characters showing courage and determination to do what’s right. Great post.

    • Thank you, Keishon. I’m glad you enjoyed the post. I really like reading about that sort of character, too, especially when it’s a well-drawn character who seems credible. I like Malla Nunn’s work very much, and I think she’s created some terrific characters. As to Mallo, I really do hope he writes a third Lescano novel, but I’ve not seen any indication there’s going to be one.

  9. Great post, Margot. The unsung heroes are the backbone of our society and make wonderful characters to read about.

  10. People never cease to amaze me by their wickedness and their amazing humanity conversely. We humans are a rum lot. Very timely piece given the state of the world.

  11. tracybham

    I have read the first two books in Rebecca Cantrell’s Hannah Vogel series and I need to read the next one. What a great series.

  12. kathy d

    I just my first Hanna Vogel novel, A Game of Lies. It was good. I’m not sure it really gave the feel for the Olympics held in Berlin in 1936. It seemed to be more about Vogel’s personal life with an ex-lover, er adopted son and friends she knew in Berlin. Some sense of the Nazis terrorizing some people and watching everyone comes across and, of course, the fear of Jewish people and the disabled.
    But I really have enjoyed Malla Nunn’s Emmanuel Cooper series. The first two books really expose apartheid’s horrors and the fourth one, too. I hope she writes more about Cooper and his secret romantic partner. Haven’t seen any notice of further books though.
    In one book by Sara Paretsky, V.I. Warshawski goes back to WWII horrors. There is a lot of bravery by a woman Jewish scientist and then by V.I. later on.

    • You make an interesting point, Kathy, that the Hannah Vogel novels really do focus on her personal life as well as the other plot threads of the books. And I’m with you about Malla Nunn’s series; it’s quite well-written, and truly has a feel for the time, place and context.

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s