Franchise Joints on Hamburger Row*

If you look at the ‘photo, you’ll probably be able to tell that it was taken in a hotel room (I’m at a conference as this is posted). But do you know which hotel? That’s a sort of trick question, really, because a lot of hotels aren’t really distinctive any more. They may have different logos, or other sorts of branding, but the major hotel chains are really quite similar in a lot of ways.

And it’s not just hotels. Many restaurants, shops, and other facilities, especially if they are part of a large chain, are almost generic in nature. That’s arguably a trend, since the larger chains have become more prevalent, whether it’s bookshops or places to have pancakes.

As with most social trends, you see that development in crime fiction, too. For example, much of Agatha Christie’s Evil Under the Sun takes places at the Jolly Roger Hotel, on Leathercombe Bay. This hotel has a long history, and by the time Hercule Poirot visits it, it’s got a fine reputation. It’s a unique sort of place with its own atmosphere. And in this novel, it becomes a crime scene when one of the guests, famous actress Arlena Stuart Marshall, is murdered nearby. At first, her husband, Captain Kenneth Marshall, is the most likely suspect. And it’s not surprising, considering the victim’s not-too-well-hidden affair with another guest. But Marshall is soon proven innocent, so Poirot and the police have to look elsewhere for the culprit. It might be interesting to consider the sort of story this would be if it took place in one of today’s more generic hotels.

Ellery Queen’s the French Powder Mystery takes place at French’s Department Store. The novel was published in 1930, before department stores were taken over by large chains. This particular store is owned by Cyrus French, who’s made it a real success. Then one day, the body of French’s wife, Winnifred, is discovered in one of the store’s window displays. Inspector Richard Queen investigates, and, of course, his son, Ellery, has quite a hand in the search for the truth. As the Queens, Sergeant Velie, and the rest of the team look into the case, we get a look at what department stores were like when they were owned by individuals. French’s is distinctive, and it’s interesting to see how that individuality comes through.

The change from the individual/unique to the more generic/mass-produced is one of the themes of Catherine O’Flynn’s What Was Lost. The story beings in 1984, when Kate Meaney is ten years old. She’s growing up in a rather dreary Midlands town, but she’s content. In fact, she’s a budding detective with her own private agency, Falcon Investigations. A new mall, Green Oaks Shopping Center, has opened, and Kate is sure that it will be a hotbed of criminal activity. So, she spends quite a lot of time there. Her grandmother, Ivy, thinks the girl would be better off going away to school, so she arranges for Kate to sit the entrance exams at the exclusive Redspoon School. Kate reluctantly agrees to go, and her friend Adrian Palmer goes along for moral support. Tragically, only Adrian returns. Despite a thorough search, no trace of Kate is found – not even a body. Twenty years later, a Green Oaks security guard named Kurt starts seeing strange images on his camera: a young girl who looks a lot like Kate. One night, he happens to meet Lisa Palmer (Adrian’s younger sister) who works at the mall. She knew Kate, and she and Kurt form a sort of awkward friendship. Each in a different way, they go back to the past, and we learn what really happened to Kate. As the novel goes on, we see the change from the individual ‘High Street’ shops to more modern large chains.

In Apostolos Doxiodis’ Three Little Pigs, we hear the story of Benvenuto ‘Ben’ Franco. In the early years of the 20th Century, he moves with his family from Italy to New York City. He gets work as a shoemaker, and is soon successful enough to have his own shoe repair/shoemaking business. Unfortunately, he gets in a bar fight with Luigi Lupo, and ends up killing the other man. He’s arrested and jailed, but that’s not the end of his trouble. It turns out that the victim is the son of notorious Mafia gangster Tonio Lupo. When Lupo learns who was responsible for his son’s death, he visits Franco in prison and curses his family. Lupo says that each of Franco’s three sons will die at the age of forty-two, the same age as Luigi was at his death. As the novel goes on, we learn how this curse plays out with Franch’s sons, Alessandro ‘Al,’ Niccola ‘Nick’ and Leonardo ‘Leo.’ While the major focus of the novel isn’t on Franco’s shoe business, we see that there’s a real difference between it and today’s mass-produced shoes.

And then there’s Kerry Greenwood’s Corinna Chapman. She is a former accountant-turned-baker, who lives and works in Melbourne. She takes pride in her bakery, Earthly Delights, where she bakes all of the bread herself, and her assistant, Jason, does the muffins himself. In Trick or Treat, a large chain, Best Fresh, opens a franchise very close to where Chapman has her bakery. Chpman’s concerned, even though Jason assures her that the competitor’s food isn’t as fresh or as tasty. Then, a young man jumps to his death from a nearby roof. Before long, his death is attributed to hallucinations brought on by ergot poisoning. All of the local bakeries, including Chapman’s, are suspect, and it’s very hard for her not to be able to do what she does – provide bread and rolls to her community. She wants to clear her bakery’s name, so she starts ask questions. And it’s interesting to see the difference between the way Chapman and her staff look at what they sell, and the way the local franchise does.

On the one hand, large chains and franchises are efficient, and can often provide goods and services at a lower cost. But there’s also something to be said for the uniqueness of independent companies. And it’s interesting to see how both are portrayed in the genre.


*NOTE:  The title of this post is a line from Brownsville Station’s The Martian Boogie.


Filed under Agatha Christie, Apostolos Doxiadis, Catherine O'Flynn, Ellery Queen, Kerry Greenwood

20 responses to “Franchise Joints on Hamburger Row*

  1. I think people like the familiar and certainly when travelling with children it is great to stay in a hotel that is part of a chain as they know what to expect but on the other hand it is sad that everywhere is becoming the same. I’m really curious about the Catherine O’Flynn story that you’ve highlighted here – I really need to read faster 😉

    • You have a well-taken point about children, Cleo. When you have young ones with you, it really does help to know what to expect. I know I found that with my daughter, and now with my granddaughter. Still, as you say, it really is sad that we’re losing the uniqueness of individual hotels. As to the O’Flunn, I can’t recommend it highly enough. It’s an excellent book. I generally try very hard to be objective about these things, but honestly, this book is superb, in my opinion. And I only wish I could read faster… 😉

  2. I don’t mind generic hotels if travelling for business, but hate them when I’m on vacation, when I want something that feels a bit more unique. Same with shops really – generic’s good for quick shopping, but boring for a casual browse. I’m with Cleo – the Catherine O’Flynn sounds good…

    • I think you really might like the O’Flynn, FictionFan. I hope you do if you read it. It really is an excellent book. And you make an interesting distinction between places you go for business or in a hurry, and places you go for fun, or to browse. I think that does make a difference. I know it does for me.

  3. I do miss the unique small businesses of the past. But those businesses mostly can’t survive these days. As far as hotels, motels go, I can go either way but I don’t travel much anyway.

    • You’re quite right, Tracy. It really is hard for a small, unique business to survive. There’s so much competition, and it’s so easy for customers to get what they want. It’s hard for a small business to make it.

  4. While I don’t mind an average/samey looking hotel room, I really do enjoy it when it looks a little different. It adds something extra to my stay and I think you find the more unusual places in novels so that we as the reader will feel immersed and part of it. Unless, as you say, the author is making a specific point and even then we can feel the drabness of that!

    • We can, indeed, Rebecca! It really is all about the point the author wants to make, isn’t it? And I’m with you about hotel rooms. I like when there’s something a little different about them – something that sets them apart and makes them unique.

  5. It’s sad in a way that business are becoming more generic in their appearances. Interesting examples, Margot.

  6. This made me think of a hotel I stayed in Sydney, Australia. Each night they would leave a card on your pillow with a different quote about sleep. I’ve got mine in front of me now. It says Sleeping is no mean art: for it’s sake one must stay awake all day. NIETZSCHE. It’s probably over ten years since I was there but I’ve still got the card! It was quite a rough and ready hotel in many ways but I loved it.

    • What a great idea for a unique touch, Victoria! I love it! And it clearly made an impression on you. That’s what I mean about those little things that we don’t always see any more. How fun!

  7. Col

    Off-topic, but the latest Michael Keaton film The Founder (ok it was last year) shows the rise of McDonalds from it’s somewhat humble origins. Not seen it yet, but it looks fairly interesting and I enjoyed Keaton’s performance in Spotlight.

  8. kathy d

    Oh, for unique places to stay. I’ve always liked bed and breakfasts or cottages or cabins in New England myself. Rarely stayed in a hotel of any kind.
    And as far as restaurants, would much rather go to a cafe as in Venice or a neighborhood restaurant than a chain.

    • Those smaller restaurants and local places are often much more appealing than the big chains, aren’t they, Kathy? I like the fact that they’re unique. And I agree; there are some fabulous small, independent hotels and B&Bs, too.

  9. You come up with the most intriguing subjects, Margot. I’ve never thought about the uniqueness or similarities of businesses in relation to the crime genre. I hope you’re having a wonderful time! What conference are you attending?

  10. Well I just have to mention Christie’s At Bertram’s Hotel – there’s a warning there about being too nostalgic about old-fashioned businesses…

What's your view? I'd love to hear it.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s